Scriptures Inspired for the L. Ray Smith Followers
76I Beseech Born-Again, Spirit-Filled Brethren
God has burdened me with the L. Ray Smith followers, and if I be called to somehow share the truth with them, if it be possible to penetrate the spirit at work, I praise God with all my heart. This hub is to provide scripture inspired as the Spirit leads to shew these that THEY WILL NOT BE SAVED THROUGH FIRE AFTER DEATH.
First of all, we must expose the root of L. Ray Smith. There was/is a hubber on HubPages called "yes2truth" who was an avid follower of this man's teaching, yet I recently stumbled upon a web-posting written by him back in March 2006 called "L. Ray Smith - The Legalist Blasphemer!" in which he states, and I quote, "Myself, like old Ray, having once been a member of Herbert W. Armstrongs's Judaising cult, and upon stumbling across ('stumbling' being a very relevant word here) L. Ray Smith's website and forum, I instantly related to his no nonsense style of preaching/teaching, which in itself is fine, and therein found much Truth being taught, but then, Hello!? I've been here before haven't I? Yes of course I had and there it was, all the time, that old stumbling block of legalism."
Now, I've already exposed Armstrongism in my hub A False Prophet of the Last Days? Another name for this cult is the Worldwide Church of God.
See, the Lord doesn't concern Himself with whether or not these people BELIEVE in HELL. Those who do not accept the Lord Jesus Christ as his/her personal Lord and SAVIOR will indeed have their eyes opened on that Day. The LORD, our Lord is only concerned with the salvation of these who will receive it, and the TRUTH shall set them FREE, AMEN.
To first get a background on their belief system, please preface by reading my hub REFUTE of SALVATION for ALL Doctrine before you pray and ask the Spirit for guidance. This is going to be a HUB OF WARFARE, and those called to post I ask to keep with us, so I don't feel like David with Goliath!! I need my brothers and sisters in the Lord that are called to this purpose to love this group together (LOVE IS THE POWER OF GOD). AMEN. I will continue to update this hub with scriptures should the Lord continue to give them to me for them.
I beseech you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God, should you be led to add inspired scripture to the comments here to prove to these followers that there truly is no salvation through fire after death, please do so. The Lord's children, the saints stand united in Jesus' Name. Where two or more agree as touching any one thing, the Lord will do it. AMEN.
Inspired by the Holy Spirit for YOU
Let's look at what happens to the spirit of man when he dies:
Ecclesiastes 3:20-21 state "All go to the same place. All came from the dust and all return to the dust. Who knows that the breath of man ascends upward and the breath of the beast descends downward to the earth?"
Now, since you don't believe in ETERNAL, let's read just three passages that show us we live after physical death for eternity (forever, not just an age or ages):
Just then there appeared before them Moses and Elijah, talking with Jesus.… Jesus instructed them, "Don't tell anyone what you have seen, until the Son of Man has been raised from the dead." (Matthew 17:1-9) I thought Moses and Elijah were DEAD?
1 Corinthians 15:52 "in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet; for the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed." Imperishable means we will never decompose (die) ~ even in the Lake of Fire.
John 11:25-26 "Jesus said to her, 'I am the resurrection and the life; he who believes in Me will live even if he dies, and everyone who lives and believes in Me will never die. Do you believe this?'"
Jesus didn't come to judge the world, right?
John 12:47 "And if anyone hears My sayings, and does NOT keep them, I do not judge him; for I did not come to judge the world, but to save the world" [Now, you might think there is no judgment and that ALL will be saved? Don't let the Devil stop you with just this verse....you must read on:]
John 12:48-49 "He who rejects Me, and does NOT receive my sayings, has ONE WHO JUDGES HIM; the word I spoke is what will judge him at the last day. For I did not speak on My own initiative, but the Father Himself who sent Me has given Me commandment, what to say, and what to speak."
Acts 17:30-31 “Therefore having overlooked the times of ignorance, God is now declaring to men that all people everywhere should repent, because He has fixed a day in which He will judge the world in righteousness through a Man [Jesus] whom He has appointed, having furnished proof to all men by raising Him from the dead."
Matthew 10:28 "And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather FEAR HIM which is able to DESTROY BOTH SOUL and BODY in HELL (geenna-Lake of Fire)." Now, since God is love, we are not to fear Him? Look up how many scriptures say to "fear God" as that of having respect. This scripture doesn't say our soul will be saved through geenna, but DESTROYED. He is an awesome God!
Romans 2:5-6 "But because of your stubbornness and unrepentant heart you are storing up wrath for yourself in the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God, who will render to every man according to his deeds."
Matthew 25:41 ""Then He will also say to those on His left, 'Depart from Me, accursed ones, into the eternal fire which has been prepared for the devil and his angels;
Let's witness the judgments of the Father:
Isaiah 47:14-15 "Behold, they have become like stubble, Fire burns them; They cannot deliver themselves from the power of the flame; There will be no coal to warm by, Nor a fire to sit before! So have those become to you with whom you have labored, Who have trafficked with you from your youth; Each has wandered in his own way. There is none to save you.
Jer 6:29-30 "The bellows blow fiercely, the lead is consumed by the fire; In vain the refining goes on, But the wicked are not separated. They call them rejected silver, Because the LORD has rejected them.
Ezekiel 18:23-28 "'Do I have any pleasure in the death of the wicked,' declares the Lord GOD, 'Rather than that he should turn from his ways and live? But when a righteous man turns away from his righteousness, commits iniquity, and does according to all the abominations that a wicked man does, will he live? All his righteous deeds which he has done will not be remembered for his treachery which he has committed; for them he will die.
"Yet you say, 'The way of the Lord is not right.' Hear now, O house of Israel! Is My way not right? Is it not your ways that are not right?
"When a righteous man turns away from his righteousness, commits iniquity, and dies because of it, for his iniquity which he has committed he will die. Again, when a wicked man turns away from his wickedness which he has committed and practices justice and righteousness, he will save his life. Because he considered and turned away from all his transgressions which he had committed, he shall surely live; he shall not die.
"But the house of Israel says, 'The way of the Lord is not right.' Are My ways not right, O house of Israel? Is it not your ways that are not right?
"'Therefore I will judge you, O house of Israel, each according to his conduct,' declares the Lord GOD. 'Repent and turn away from all your transgressions, so that iniquity may not become a stumbling block to you. Cast away from you all your transgressions which you have committed, and make yourselves a new heart and a new spirit! For why will you die, O house of Israel?
"'For I have no pleasure in the death of anyone who dies,' declares the Lord GOD. 'Therefore, repent and live.'"
Let's now go back to the New Testament
John 17:9 "I ask on their behalf; I do NOT ask on behalf of the WORLD, but of those whom Thou hast given Me; for they are Thine."
2 Thessalonians 1:6-10 “For after all it is only just for God to repay with affliction those who afflict you, and to give relief to you who are afflicted and to us as well when the Lord Jesus will be revealed from heaven with His mighty angels in flaming fire, dealing out retribution to those who do not know God and to those who do not obey the gospel of our Lord Jesus. These will pay the penalty of eternal destruction, away from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of His power, when He comes to be glorified in His saints on that day, and to be marveled at among all who have believed-- for our testimony to you was believed.”
2 Peter 2:6 and 9 "And if He condemned the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah to destruction by reducing them to ashes, having made them an example to those who would live ungodly thereafter; then the Lord knows how to rescue the godly from temptation, and to keep the unrighteous under punishment for the day of judgment.
2 Peter 3:7 "But the present heavens and earth by His word are being reserved for fire, kept for the day of judgment and destruction of ungodly men."
1 John 5:5 "And who is the one who overcomes the world, but he (YOU) who believes that Jesus is the Son of God?"
Acts 13:46 "Then Paul and Barnabas waxed bold, and said, It was necessary that the word of God should first have been spoken to you: but seeing ye put it from you, and judge yourselves unworthy of everlasting life, lo, we turn to the Gentiles."
Every Tongue Confess is NOT Salvation
Philippians 2:10-11 first states "that at the name of Jesus EVERY KNEE SHOULD BOW, of those who are in heaven, and on earth, and under the earth, and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father."
James 2:19 states "You believe that God is one. You do well; the demons also believe, and shudder."
Matthew 8:29 the demons named Legion confess, "And they cried out, saying, 'What business do we have with each other, Son of God? Have You come here to torment us before the time?'" The word "torment" is "torture".
1 Corinthians 13:5 states that Love does not seek its own way. While it's God's desire that all should be saved, He will not force anyone to be saved through judgment or any other means. God is love and love does not force its own way.
Unless the Father Draws (Drags) Him?
John 6:44 states, "No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him; and I will raise him up on the last day." Do you think the Father will NOT draw some? You are wrong, according to John 12:32: "But I, when I am lifted up from the earth, will draw ALL men to myself."
Does this mean ALL will be saved? Some will reject His calling based on John 12:48 "He who rejects Me and does not receive My sayings, has one who judges him; the word I spoke is what will judge him at the last day."
Obviously, those who hear the Word will be drawn unto Christ by the Spirit of God, for Ephesians 2:8 states "For by grace are you saved through faith". Since we know that faith comes by hearing the Word of God (Rom 10:17), and yet man can reject the Word of God (His sayings), that is a choice. Jesus said He draws ALL MEN to Himself. There is no excuse.
For those who have NEVER heard the Word of God, they are without sin, the Word says in John 15:22 "If I had not come and spoken to them, they would not be guilty of sin. Now, however, they have no excuse for their sin." Why do you think the Apostles and all believers are to go all throughout the world to spread the gospel? That is the Great Commission!
vote upvote downshareprintflag
- Useful
- Funny (3)
- Awesome (1)
- Beautiful
- Interesting (1)
Pathetic. He doesn't have followers. Give me a break. It's just a web site, and since you can't prove him wrong you falsely acuse him of being a cult. You need to read on his site "Ray answers Florida Bible College Professor" I would love to see you and Ray in a one on one conversation about anything. I know what would happen and I think you do too. You just won't admit it. It's called PRIDE. No one wants to be proven wrong, and not many people will admit to being wrong. It takes more of a person to admit they are wrong.
Hi Carrie, sorry it took so long for me to respond to your call. I had to go to L. Ray Smith's website to read his article. He clearly has it wrong, and this is why: In Matthew 3:11, which he cites, where John the Baptist says: "I indeed baptize you with water unto repentance: but He that cometh after me is mightier than I, whose shoes I am not worthy to bear: He shall baptize you with the Holy Ghost, and with fire". The verb is used metaphorically in two distinct senses:
1. Of "baptism" by the Holy Spirit which took place on the day of Pentecost;
2. Of the calamity which would come upon the nation of the Jews, a "baptism" of FIRE of divine judgement for rejection of the will and word of God. Matthew 3:11; Luke 3:16.
The reference he (L. Ray Smith) makes to Revelation 20:11-14, about the lake of fire is the second death, which the saints have no part in. Revelation 20:15 clearly says that "whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire".
So, not only is this taking place after the Church is gone out of the world, the Rapture, but it clearly says in verse 13 that this is a JUDGEMENT not a purification.
I hope this could be of some assistance to your courageous work.
God Bless
The Lord bless your heart and fortify your spirit, sister, as you stand in the gap for these people.
Carrie,
Answer a Fool according to a Fool...
All of the Christians are believing that JL. We all wish for you to know peace from the Prince of Peace.
Only thing I have to say here is that no matter who is the best debater, no matter who thinks they know what, God is not mocked and He does indeed see the intent of the heart.
I would like to see Ray in a one on one with God. Job had a one on one with Him so why couldn't Ray do the same?
So many say they are called to preach against the church. Some are "called" to preach against preachers. hey do everything in their power to make everyone else look bad. Jezebel did the same thing and look what happened to her.
It is time to preach the gospel of Christ and let everything else alone.
If I should get rid of every bit of pride in me, would I then have pride in the fact that I got rid of it and be right back where I started? ~~~ SirDent
A person who tries to make everyone else look the fool becomes the fool in the eyes of all who know it. ~~~ SirDent
One more thing I must point out here. Satan uses scripture to teach also, yet Jesus said Satan is a liar and the truth is not in him.
Nothing more left to be said here.
Carrie, I enjoy reading these hubs of yours because it's clear that God is doing some mighty works here, using you and your false doctrines to lead others to truthful study and Scriptures. When your done playing with childish things, and ready to learn to truths about God's Word, come see me, God willing.
I rejoice in your persecution. Thanks for promoting Ray's site where others can go God willing, and learn the truths about proper study and The Good News... not your pagan man-made doctrines. Your outright lies and twistings of the Scriptures will be clear to those that God has given clear vision to.
You might want to pray that God gives you a humble heart cause that pride of yours is starting to smell of rot.
It seems it finally happened Dan. Your true colors are shining through. Not one time have I read where you tried to teach or spread the gospel of Christ.
I recall that God told Samuel, "Do not weep for Saul, for I have rejected him." God hates certain things also. Read about them in Proverbs.
jacobbsladdr says:7 hours ago I rejoice in your persecution.
SirDent says right now: Why would you rejoice in the persecution of anyone? Do you rejoice in your own persecution?
It seems to me that Carrie is stronger than many of you think. She certainly isn't a pushover and it is not because of her own self. It is the Holy Ghost which strengthens her. Leave her alone and let her be.
Jezebel did everything she could to destroy Elijah. She had 450 prophets come up against him. She prophesised that he would be killed and the dogs would eat his flesh. It is funny how things get turned around. When you wish and prohesy evil upon one of God's children, the same evil you prophesy will come upon you.
Carrie, I truly believe your heart is good. We are called to spread the gospel. God will take care of them once they believe.
Carrie, I understand God in this fashion. Our children do stupid things sometimes.It is natural after all. When they do something that should embarrass us, do we turn pour backs on them? If they end up causing a lot of trouble, do we turn our backs on them? NO!!! We may not approve of something they did, but we still love them and will take care of them. Gods is the same way. He will always take care of His children and will send encouraging help when needed.
Now some children who are not mine, I will not back up like mine. Some are children of Satan and God will not treat them as He does His own children.
I hope this is clear to you. May the Lord bless you abundantly above all that you can contain that it spills over onto others around you.
The very idea that all will be saved is utterly ridiculous. Wishful thinking at best; though it could be something far worse. There will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. You did a fine job refuting this false doctrine. Bully for you! And God Bless You!
and i thought God is love and love never fails. wishing thinking i guess
Philo and agape love. Philo is the stronger love that people have for those close. I haven't studied the usuage of how God uses love on all (whether philo or agape) but He does love all. To say otherwise is heresy. But what's new?
Dear fellow siner
It seems you have missed the point about judgment. Don't worry though because your eyes will be opened in future!God's mercy never ends and mercy will always rejoice over judgment.
where did abrahams faith come from since he came before the writen word. Jesus said it plainly enough, you did not choose me but I choose you. Also is judas in this hell of yours or is he in heaven? Before you answer this Rev. says that on the foundation of the new city is writen the names of the twelve apostles. why would God put the name of a person who supposedly is responsible for Jesus's death on the holy city. Also it would do you good to look up the definition of judgement before saying it is different from correction. Jesus's was commisioned by the Father to be the saviour of not only you but the entire world. I think your problem is not with L. Ray Smith but with Gods word. Please read 2Cor.3:14 ,4:4. God loves us all! I pray that it be Gods will for your life while your on this earth that you understand the good news! With love, Thaddeus Cole
for God so loved the World that He gave His only begotten Son, THAT WHOEVER BELIEVES IN HIM SHALL NOT PERISH BUT HAVE ETERNAL LIFE. 1Tim.2:4,5 is this scrpture a lie or the truth. With love, Thaddeus Cole. P.S. Were we believers before Jesus made His sacrifice? He instructs us to be like Him, should our love be different from His?
1Tim.4:10 please explain this little scripture for me, and please make it understandable. Also you might want to look up the word HELL in the old english, which is what the KJV. was translated into to begin with. Study to show thyself approved! with LOVE, Thaddeus Cole
First off you did not answer the first question. Second, if He choose the twelve then by nessity he chooses all. third, was Paul an apostle, how about titus and all those after! Jesus said, I chose you the twelve and one of you is a devil. these are the ones JESUS chose. Judas died thats the reason there was only 11 at the time you refer to. You said it yourself, He chose these 12 to be His apostles, did He mess up! You refer to Jam.4:4 as your proof that all aren't saved. Do you actually believe he is talking about the peoples of this world or the lusts there of? Forthly 2Cor. you state that in Christ the veil is removed, and the minds of the unbelieving, if you don't believe what the scripture says of Christ then you are unbelieving. God says to love and pray for your enemies! Do we expect less of our Father who is perfect! Fifth, 1 Tim2:4-5 will Gods desires not be fulfilled or does he just wish that it could be so? I do know that the only salvation we have is through Christ! Thats as plain as the rest of what I have been talking about, but what does that have to do with the salvation of all? Where does the SCRIPTURES say conversion has to come before our bodies die? If that were so it would be in scripture, would it not? Also when Jesus asked Peter who he thought He was, Jesus said blessed are you for flesh and blood did not revell this, but our Father in heaven. In laymans terms: you did not know this of your own intelligents but God allowed him this knowledge. God is soverein in all things not just what our pride thinks He is! To say that God gave up His son for people who he only loved socially is behond me. God is drawing all men and women to Him and that is Gods truth! To say that you choose Jesus because it was availible is an insult to God Who works ALLTHINGS according to the council of HIS WILL. God has ordered your steps not you. If you attained something then why do you boast as though you didn't? You want me to read a hub but I pray you read scripture! I do love all people! Once I didn't, I guess that makes me a enemy of God right?
Know one said that Jesus was not the only way to salvation! God unlike man knows the beging to the end! That is how he can say that Jesus is the saviour of all men TO BE TESTIFIED IN DUE TIME! We ourselves are ignorant of the end, except for the knowledge God gives through His Word and His spirit. God one great day will be ALL in ALL. Just as All are guilty in Adam, so shall all be saved through Christ! God unlike man knows the hearts of every man, we do not. Who pray tell will we reign and teach when Jesus returns for the second time. Mans heart is FULL of pride and God and only God can rid us of it. I wish you well and may what you teach glorify God! A servant of Christ Thaddeus Cole through Gods will and not my own. P.S. I wish your answers to my questions were more to the point of the question, but I figured as much. God bless you and even though I believe by your stance on salvation you are very carnal does not mean I don't love you like a sister. One day we both will stand side by side with our saviour Jesus! Untill that day I bid you good-bye!
God has given Jesus ALL things, some things we can't see as yet. That is what faith is! Just because I haven't seen Jesus ressurected does not mean it is so. When will Abraham confess Jesus as being Gods only begotten Son and believe in Him as the sacrifice for his sin since he is sleeping with his fathers untill Jesus returns. I feel your frustration I to have been in your shoes for many years. with love again Thaddeus Cole
why did you not post my last comment? did I say something to offend you and yes it is in the bible! 1Cor15:22 says so! What are the wages of sin but death, or do you know of a nother! In Christ all are made alive each in his own turn! If that is not salvation then what is? Jesus died for all men, especially for those who believe now not exclusivly. You call it my doctrine! Then what is it you teach? Seeing that eternal is not in the original manuscripts or forever and ever! Sounds as though there is an ever after forever like in kids books. I'm stund to hear that! I will shake the dust from my feet on this one. with love for you. Do you not read that every knee shall bow, and every tonge acclaim Jesus is lord to the glory of God the Father. Then he will throw them in the lake of fire eternally. Doesn' sound like a doctrine our loving Father would have given the trates of God writen in His word
did those same demons believe Jesus as their LORD and only saviour. Stan has no power over anything, God is soviern. He is over all things. Why do you give him credit for anything. God says I created evil and good. The devil had to get promission from God to do what he did to Job! Jesus said you have NO power over me but what the Father has given you. Why does God let the devil do what he does? Because He already knows the outcome. God did not go to plan B.He has a perfect plan A. Do you even know what the old english meaning of hell is? why is hell thrown into the lake of fire along with death? why did the old english people put their potatos in hell. Give me a brake,you know the words of scripture but your understanding of them is far from being correct! I know you want post all of what I write and that is sad but it is true. Just like your answers to the questions I've asked, they answer none of them. Your tring to side step the real question. Just like you said about not being in the bible, you knew full well it was in there. you did not even post the one comment i made. How sad coming from someone who claims to be a teacher of Gods.I still do love you though Thaddeus Cole
The KJV was translated into old english. A quick search on the computer can lay that point to rest. You said the devil is in control of the unsaved how can that be. The devil does tempt us but in control, I think not. Only God is in control of anything. Hell is pit with out a bottom plus it is thrown into the lake of fire. I thought you said you either went to heaven or hell for eternity now then hell is trown there,so where do we actually spend eternity hell or the lake of fire. You say that a SOUL is eternal. Do you know that God took a body breathed His spirit into it and it became a living soul. When you die your spirit gos back to God who gave it and that living soul dies. It is not alive in some other location it is dead untill God resurrects it from where? The dead! You have no knowledge in death or preception if you would have it. Imortallity has been given to Jesus only at this time and age. No one is in heaven know but Him. Where I go you cannot follow but I will come again and receive you unto myself that where I am so shall you be also. Like I said before, you have lack in understanding Gods truths but that is not your fault. As you said all you have to do is ask. By the way did Jesus not ask God to let this cup pass over me? The very next words out of his mouth is, but let not My will be done but yours. until another day, may God bless all. To the glory of God the Father. In love Thaddeus Cole
So what is the Lake of Fire and what happens to people in it? I want to really know what you think happens to these people for eternity.
OK, so what's the brimstone for?
so jesus went to paridise the day he died? The sign that jesus gave them was that he would be in the heart of the earth 3 days, not in paridise. Healso told God, I commit my spirit to you and then died. Also brimstone is used in purification of metals! You said it sounds like a volcano. Do you remember telling me that hell is the grave. How can that be the lake of fire also? God ressurects all the dead small and great. Hell and the grave give up thoce who are in them. Does God put them back in and then throw hell back in. Your body after resurrection is a spiritual body not a physical one. How can literal fire hurt a spiritual body? It doesn't! The fire it self is also spiritual. God Himself is the spiritual fire that consumes. Rev. is a book of symbols. I'm glad you spoke of sodom and gomorrah. God's word said it would be more better for them in the day of judgement than others! does this mean they will only stay a billion years or is the tempature turned down a little for them. The scriptures as given by God in their orginal form do not contridict themselves. Do you know what contridiction is? Go up to about 2 or 3 comments and see were you do it. With love,Thaddeus Cole
So you believe satan to be a God? Do you understand what you are saying because you clearly don't understand what God says. Just because this world is evil just as satan is does not make him a god. There is one God and One mediator between God and man. Sounds like only one God to me, unless you lack understanding spiritually and in figuritive language. Sorry if it seems I'm being hostle, I'm not. You said that if the soul stays with the body, the soul is the body once you add the life giving spirit of God. read Gen. God made man in 2 stages, He formed him from the dust of the earth, then he breathed the spirit of life into him! This made Adam not just a lump of clay anymore but a living soul. He did not put a soul in him. The very fact that He gave him the spirit of life made man a living soul.With love, Thaddeus Cole
Interesting that you haven't answered how brimstone contribues to the torture of sinners. It does not make fire any hotter. What's most interesting is that you fail to realize that sulphur has been used for thousands of years to purify for religious ceremonies. It's even been used in medicines. Perhaps God knew about all of this before it was ever used to make pills for WW2 soldiers. Now, your volcano example doesn't surprise me. I know that you lend credence to the ridiculous notion that hell is inside of the Earth. So the Lake of Fire is not literal fire at all. It's literal magma and god couldn't tell the difference. Guess he shoulda hung around volcanic erruptions to see what happens when lava cools and compare it to what happens when fire cools.
But now I am clear that you think the Lake of Fire is for the soul purpose of torture. Oh yes, and since you didn't answer what the people in the LOF are or will be doing, I imagine you'll say, "why, they are weeping and nashing teeth" (or you can correct me on that). But Carrie, what do you really think they will be doing? Perhaps a lot of screaming? Forget asking for a drop of water. They're on fire aren't they? We want to know what you really think is physically happening in the Lake of Fire.
Also if we are in the lake of fire for eternity would we not to have had been there from the begining or do we just pick when eternity should start?
Also 1Tim. 4:10 does say especially those who believe! With love,Thaddeus Cole
I never said that hell was in outer space. I've already shown several times that hell is a mistranslation and the doctrine is absurd. So in other words, it doesn't exist. You keep talking about the rich man in hell as if that parable is talking about one person. That parable is talking about the entire Jewish nation under the headship of Judah. Perhaps it can be refering to the Great white Throne Judgment for gentiles, but it is most definately refering to the 2000 year old plight of the Jewish nation. I wrote a hub showing this specificaly. It's a fair summary of what Ray Smith wrote but don't let that interfere with your reading it and learning something. Again, a drop of water? Please!! Have you no spiritual recognition? Gnashing of teeth? Not the best description of being on fire if you ask me. I bet you couldn't hold your finger in a flame for 3 seconds without screaming. And you think one on fire would request a drop of water? I also noticed your spiritual belch when you said that the people in the graves and the oceans that never believed will be cast into the LOF. . . . . . .The oceans? Have that many people been lost at sea that the seas is refering to oceans in Revelation? And so we learn that all who have not believed will be burned with searing heat for all eternity. Oh those poor Bushmen of that African desert that I can't spell. And the Aboriganies, and those who never questioned their parent's beliefs. The doctrine of hell reaches the very depths of insanity.
Again, if you think that section in Revelation is talking about the oceans, you have the spiritual recognition of a fetus. It's funny actually that you said that. What isn't funny is how you twist what I say. First I never said that anybody was going to your hell. What I said, is the Jewish people in general have lost out on the gifts promised to them by God because they haven't payed close enough attention to realize that the Messiah has indeed come.
The rich man was dressed in purple which denotes royalty. Judah was to carry the royal line in Israel.
And cambric: Symbolic of the clothing priests wore. Judah had both the Scepter and the Priesthood.
. . . .child, be reminded. ..
Judah was of the line of Abraham. The rich man speaks of 5 brothers. Judah had 5 brothers through his mother Leah. The entire sequence is speaking of the general Jewish population, who until about 60 years ago, had no home land, have been persecuted greatly, and still are clueless as to who their savior is.
As for Lazarus? He is said to be in Abraham's bosom showing a very close emotional relationship. Abram had promised all of his possessions to be inherited by his faithful steward Eliezer. But this promise was taken away once Isaac was born. Eliezer remained faithful and even found a wife for Isaac. And guess what Carrie, Eliezer was a gentile. Gentiles were refered to as dogs by the Jews of that time. Eliezer is a representation of Lazarus. In that parable, Lazrus is a representation of gentiles. No, not all gentiles. Only those gentiles who remaine faithful in adverse situations. And Abraham's bosom is not the Christian heaven. Nor is it the coming salvation of the faithful. It represents comfort for those who are stuggling in this life but have the assurance of the rewards to come. Some have this genuine comfort (I'm not talking about the false beliefs of this world). But the rich man is speaking of those who had much either in life or in their early Jewish heritage. This is thoroughly explained in my hub about the rich man and Lazarus. And no, the rich man hasn't been given any assurance of getting out of that condition. But he will be judged and shown the truths in time and will receive all of the gifts once Christ is ready to present them.
Oh, once more, to answer your first question. No, Lazarus was not a Jew.
You need to do alot of studing on two words, hell and eternity. That would clear alot of this up. If it is a spiritual body then flames want never hurt it since it would have no nervice system. What is the flame and heat for, light or warmth. Every lair Will have their part in the lake of fire right. Jesus did for the pentilty of sin which is death. The carnal thinking of man has to be destroyed after Jesus brings us back to life. Have you ever told a lie carrie? You will say yes, Jesus paid the price for me! He did pay the pentilty for sin which is death! When made alive again what or who will rid us of the carnal thoughts that made us lie in the first place. You said that jesus is God! thats how he went to paradise. No my dear Jesus is the Son of God! That is part of the faith that saves us from death! The more you are confronted with the truth the more you throw in untruths. There is ONE GOD and ONE MEDIATOR between God and man, JESUS!Just because me and my son look alike, think alike, act alike does not make him me. He is my son and always will be. Just because people believe in pagon gods does not make them so. Jesus hands over the kingdom to His Father so that all will be all in God. Why is that if both are God or is that just a play on words. I guess God hands the kingdom over to Himself, even thuogh it is Him who already has it. You say your doctrin is one of life and mine is one of death.Funny how yours has trillions tortured for ever because the devil was to strong. While the one I believe has all men repentant and living under Gods love for the eons.Now which one was death and which was life again? I feel so sad for you but for a reason God has blinded you and I know one day the truth will be taught to you and you to will repent and believe in Christ as LORD. With love Thaddeus Cole
So again, you fail to see simple examples that I use concerning that obvious parable. Lazarus being a Jewish name does not have anything to do with why that name represents the gentiles. The name meant helpless. But let's not let that confuse us. You think that story is literal truth when it has countless instances of symbolism. I shouldn't be surprised because you no doubt think that Revelation is literal. Except you think the fire is magma. Just a slight difference I suppose. By the way, wouldn't you think burning people with fire would be torture? We know it says torment and this doesn't mean torture. It's not we who think people are burned literally in some hell hole for eternity. I would still like to hear what you think these people are doing while being eternally burned.
The Holy spirit procedes from the father. It is not another person of God. You are right it is God! Jesus on the other hand is THE SON OF GOD! Don't double talk, answer my question please. If jesus is God why does He hand over the kingdom to the Father so that all may be all in God? If Jesus is God then all would already be all in God. Why does Jesus not know the day or the hour of His own return, just the Father knows. If you can answer these two questions to the point instead of something that has nothing to do with what I asked. Ask anyone with half a brain and they will tell you that throwing someone in a lake of fire for any amount of time would be torture. Then tell them it will be for an eternity and they will not die. Then tell them the reason they were thrown there, some of which never even heard of God or of Christ. All of these that were cast there bowed and proclaimed Christ as Lord by the spirit of God but they were sent there anyway. See what they would say? Why not ask God yourself! Thats what I did. I once went to jails and prisons and taught, I had alot of concerns about what I taught. My pastor was of no help he also double talked. It was hard for me to let go of the doctrins of men which I was taught from childhood! Praise be to God that not only was I called of God but I was also choosen By Him and it was not the other way around. I played church for 35 years before He gave me the Knowledge of truth. God has mercy on some and some He hardens in this life but God never tortures His childern. To say that you want be moved is false, God can move you if it be His will. With love, Thaddeus Cole
Uuuuuuuummmm?? So what's the revelation? Aaahh, did it occur to you that parables are also symbolism? So, the non literal but real fire and brimstone of Revelation is only tormenting rather than torturous. So, do the inhabitants actually feel this non literal but real fire and brimstone? (Excuse me, I meant magma and brimstone.) Or is it just a lot of smoke getting in their spiritual eyes. I mean, they can't feel it, right? Oh yeah, they would have to if they were screaming as you suggest when you lend credence to those Russian's digging into hell. After all, it's literal. . .. .or non literal brimstone down in the Earth? I'm confused. I don't think you know what you are talking about again. So which is it Carrie? Are people screaming way down under the crust of the earth, or don't they feel anything. . . . .meaning they wouldn't be screaming? Have you thought about any of your absurd beliefs or does your religion not allow this? Are those born into pagan cultures going to wallow in pain forever or do you think God had a plan for them? It's time for you to come clean. What is the purpose of the Lake of Fire and do spiritual beings suffer pysically. . ..or. . . .non physically, although only at the level of torment. . . . Help me out, I don't know what you think. Is it literal fire or magma, and can the people there actually feel it? And since you don't really know the word of God in my oppinion, stop quoting scriptures that you don't understand. I want your oppinion on what the Lake of Fire is, does, and causes.
So it's felt. What, the gnashing of teeth or the fire? Gnashing of teeth has nothing to do with pain. Before they stoned Silas they gnashed their teeth at him. No rest, is only felt in a physical sense. Spiritual bodies don't sleep. It's speaking of the torment of being shown truths that you refuse to believe at the moment. Again, don't give me scriptures concerning the LOF because you don't even know what it is. Now that you have ignorantly stated that the LOF is felt physically, please show why a god of perfection would send illinformed people to it eternally.
Boy, where do I start? Jesus never said that all would not be saved. Never did He say that. There are conditions to being saved. That I know. But He never said that these conditions would not eventually be met for all. Just as you said, God draws all men to Himself. That's what I've been saying. Just not everybody now. The fact that it says all, proves my point.
Now for the most ludicrous part of your last post: The stench of sulphur? Sulphur only has stench when mixed with other agents. Sulphur was used as a fumigant for religious ceremonies for god's sake. Thirsty? Your rich man assumtion is just more Babylonian twaddle. Torment does not have to be felt physically. This is ridiculous. Often kids are bullied by words alone. That in itself is tormenting. Having a job that you can't stand with bosses yelling at you can be tormenting. Going to prison and being locked up in a small cell most of the day is tormenting. Where do you come up with such untruth? I think it's really time for you to consider the notion of eternal pain. Trust me, if you can bring your mind to wrap around this idea, you will begin to beg for truth. Because you obviously don't have it.
Oh, and just to answer what you said to the other poster: Hell did not mean pit in Old English. It meant to cover. Where do you think we got the word helmet from? Still, they found a way to use it to support a terrible false doctrine.
Carrie, How are you its good to see the Lord at Work. I only see the Scripture one way God's Word is True and never change's. Jesus is the Spirit of Prophecy His Word is Truth.
If the Prophet of God Zechariah speaks these Words then they are from the Spirit of Jesus Christ. I will bring the third part though the Fire to be refined as fine Gold or Silver. It is clear that not all will be able to call Him The Lord there GOD. Amen
K.J.V. Zec 13:8.9 8And it shall come to pass, that in all the land, saith the LORD, two parts therein shall be cut off and die; but the third shall be left therein.
9And I will bring the third part through the fire, and will refine them as silver is refined, and will try them as gold is tried: they shall call on my name, and I will hear them: I will say, It is my people: and they shall say, The LORD is my God.
First death, then purification. By the way, death certainly does not mean screaming in fire.
Frist thing I want to address is LOVE! You claim that agape love is only that with the Father and brethren. You claim agapao is the love for the world. Is that what you meant to say? Because, according to the strongest strongs exhaustive concordence of the bible you are flat wrong. Page 1587 agapao #25v. GK:26[26,27]. to love; in the NT usually the active love of God for his Son and his people, and the active love his people are to have for God, each other,and EVEN ENEMIES:- love [73], loved [39], loveth [20], beloved[7], lovest [2], lovedst [1]! Agape, GK: 27[25]. love, in the NT usually the active love of God for his Son and his people, and the active love his people are to have for God, each other, and even enemies; Do you see your era? Now to the next point. You said were is purification in the word judgment? From the NIV compact dictionary of the bible(Isa 2:12; Hos 5:8; Amos 5:18) Qoet, "The purpose of the judgment is purification! In the NT, as well as the OT, judgment is the aspect of the deliverance of believers. So you see Carrie you need to STUDY. With love, Thaddeus Cole
I have wrote were I got my info? strong's strongest exhaustive concordence of the bible! Qoet,"the most up-to-date Hebrew and Greek dictionaries for PRECISE word study. Fully revised and corrected! Did you read from what was qoeted??? Do you think that James4:4-5 is saying not to love or be the friend of the people of the world or the things in the world such as evil, lust, self-righteousness, etc. If that is what you think then I don't believe you have any discernment. As far as purification, that part is from the NIV compact dictionary of the bible which I said in the comment if you had read the whole thing. I read the new spirit filled life bible NKJV,the NIV study bible,the interlinear bible hebrew, greek and english,holy bible KJV. These are the only ones I have at this time. Do I need another? Read my dear what was writen then look at the resource qoeted from, then give a comment. As far as misquote, I kill those but I don't get scripture from. I pull out books and read. If I don't have that resource I call a relative who is a professor at memphis state. Who sends that resource to me via the post office. The meek shall inherit the earth! Unless you become like one of these little children you shall never see the kingdom of God. God's judgments make us hummble, meek. They let us know who is in control. When we feel proud they bring us low. That is purification. If not it is punishment for no reason. If you do not learn from a judgment then that one wasn't enough. But to punish for eternity? What is the benifit of such a judgment? Where is the righeousness in this kind of judgment? In my NKJV they have changed words where world was in place of ages or age! That must have been a wrong translation of aion or aionions. Are there more revisions to come? will you still defend eternity in hell, in the lake of fire when that to has been corrected. With love, Thaddeus Cole. P.S. you need an up-dated concordance!
read your bible and quit typing in kee words my dear. Judgment is used to correct not torture! Read in strong's dictionary where it says design of - Judgments = to correct, to hummble ! It then gives about 30 or 40 scriptures to reference. I don't think you will read them but there it is for your seeing. With love, Thaddeus Cole
I have given you you def. of agape and agapao from, once again I will say strongest strong's exhaustive concordence of the bible! They are the same definition. Did you read my first comment it was word for word out of strong's? Agape also has, love feast, the common meal shared by christians in connection with church meetings. Other than that there is no difference between the two! Both state,even enemies! What are you reading? With love,Thaddeus Cole
Once again you have left out a comment that I made. So I will restate it for you. Under the word jugdments in the strongest strong's exhaustive concordance of the bible it states. Design of: To correct, to humble. I am sorry if you do not understand but when you ask what something has to do with something else or when you give the definition of a word or words that are not right you will be answered. The gaul of you to say that I read some extra biblical book when I gave you what I read. With love, Thaddeus Cole
No carrie they are not! According to what I read they are different words with the same meaning. Do you have the strongest strong's or an older version? That may be your problem! You need a revised edition, or corrected edition. When was yours published? I would hate to disagree because of a revision problem. With love, Thaddeus Cole
forgive them Father, for they not what they do? What does that imply? That he prays for people who do not believe of course. With love, Thaddeus Cole
Carrie, I have given you the name, page, def. Me nor L. Ray Smith have writen this book or the NIV compact dictionary of the bible but it doesn't jive with what you say. I'm sure there is a bible bookstore or online version of the strongest strong's exhaustive concordance of the bible that you can get. I'm sure that some of your readers will. If your dictionary has been revised carrie then you need to know what has changed! Again, what I read from was the strongest strong's exhaustive concordance of the bible. Now look in that one. If there is a different def. Than what you have then it is a problem of revision and you need to know which came first. The last being the most reliable. Can you understand that. If you can't and refuse to read the book I have listed then we have nothing to gain by this exchange. See I have both, actually 3 of strong's books and the one I read is the newest hince the name strongest strong's exhaustive concordance. I'm not going to argue with you. When you post a comment that I know to be false I will expose it. That is to keep the ones God chooses from being deceived. Me and you both have a mission from God but they surely are very different ones I am afraid. With love, Thaddeus Cole
Do you proof read? you said the reason Jesus prayed what He did was because they were jews. No carrie the romans put Jesus on the cross! Yes the jews had a hand in it to but there were more people there besides the jews. If you know the bible we have been grafted in. Boy when God blinds He really blinds um. You say my founder, You must be talking about my Lord and Saviour Jesus the Christ! The scripture does not contridict but people like you do. Just go through and read all the comments you wrote. Although you probally will not see.Just read what I've put before you? You will not but someone who comes along will. You won't because you feel you are right, so what will it hurt unless you are wrong. I read your study tool. Not very exhaustive is it. Go and read if you have the time then tell me what you've read. Both are writen by James strong,ll.d., s.t.d. So there could not be a difference could there. Just like the KJV bible many revisions go into it. With Love, Thaddeus Cole
No my dear they are studing everything they can get there hands on not the back of the KJV bible. they are studing and finding mistranslations just as God would have them. You can not read one thing and think you know all. Studt to show thyself approved. If you do not have honest study then you are in jeapordy of being wrong as you are. With love, Thaddeus Cole
Carrie, the Jews were to be a type and shadow of the true elect of Christ. Christ was sent to save the world. However, the house of Israel represents the chosen who will reign with Christ for the milinium. Obviously, most of the Jews from that time on will not be in the first ressurection. But the true (and I do mean true) believers of the last 2000 years are the spiritual Jews. When Christ asked that all be forgiven, He was speaking of all mankind. Because of His great sacrifice, all have been forgiven for all sins. However, this does not eliminate the sin. It must be removed. But for mankind to have these sins removed ever, they must first be forgiven. This has happened.
what is so complicated about Jesus being the savior of the world and that HE WILL ACCOMPLISH HIS WILL...and that it does NOT please Him to loose ONE! Not ONE! What is so hard to believe about that! He asks US to forgive and forgive and forgive and YET HE is above that commandment and will NOT FORGIVE ultimately?? And that is JUST and that brings GLORY to HIS NAME?? Who's making up what? I very much HATE this "God" that I once believed in and that you still believe in!!!
Carrie, I've been reading you exchanges for a while. Are you saying that Hell No and Thad are under powerful delusions and are condemned? It seems to me that they also love God and Jesus as much as you do from reading your arguements altho I find their God more humane and loving than yours, carrie. I hope you will continue corresponding because I am learning a lot. I might learn to love this God that you are efending from your different point of views. Yhud and Hell No, please continue to discuss.
Carrie, you haven't answered hell no's question about your God torturing or tormenting (or whatever) the less informed aborigines or bushmen (or something to this effect) who were not reached by the word of God. Will He really? Just yes or no. Your answer will help me decide whether I can love or have a relationship with your kind of God. Again, just yes or no.
No, carrie, it did not. I really just want to hear a yes or no from you. My question was so simple: Will your God torture them for all eternity?
Okey let me ask you a similar one for this is closer to my heart. I am a product of a Higaonon tribe in my country Philippines. I am now a city boy tho. My grandparents were the leaders of our tribe. I remembered how they were looked up to by our people for simply being good. Because of them there was peace and the people were never hungry and never have to worry about tribal feuds for my grandpa was also a good statesman. Sadly, though, they were never reached by your gospel. I don't remember missionaries going to our place in the boondocks. They died natural deaths without ever hearing or receiving this Jesus of yours.
Will your God torment them for eternity, carrie? Again this is a simple question that can be answered by a yes or a no. Your answer will help me decide whether I will embrace your message.
Thud and hell no, What will your God do to my grandparents?
You also did not answer my question if you are saying that Thud and Hell No are under pwerful delusions. Again just a yes or no. This would tell me something about your heart, carrie.
I am in search of spiritual truths...
Is that a no? He will not be tormenting them? Whew! what a relief. At least my grandparents, by not being presented with the gospel (which they might have or could have rejected, i dont know), are in heaven for simply being good. Thats really good news. Please tell me more.
But wait, I forgot to mention to you that in our tribe we worhipped forest gods, river gods and field gods. We even do rituals for the dead that they might have a better life in the next. Well, we did not know of this Jesus or this God of yours. Nobody went up to us to tell us.
Will they still be in heaven, carrie? Or will they be tormented by your God?
So your God will be torturing them for eternity because they did not know Jesus? Nobody told them. Their worship of their gods were already in their culture before they were born. Why didnt your God chose to have them born in America or somewhere were they will continually be exposed to this gospel of yours. Or at least born into a tribe where there is no pagan worship. At least they will surely go to heaven for simply being good people even if they did not hear of this Jesus of yours. Its unfair. I love them so much. My grandpa used to bring me to hunt deer and wild pigs. I guess God favored some because they were born into areas where this gospel is being preached everyday.
I still believe its not fair for your God , Carrie, to be tormenting my oldfolks. They did not get the same chance as you. I don't know. I am just devastated right now.
Again I just want a clear confirmation from you. Just a simple yes or no. Will your God, Carrie, torture my lola and lolo (grannies) for eternity?
Hello, carrie? You still did not answer my last post.
Anyway, from your first answer I get the thought that since my grandparents would have been saved by virtue of their being good had they not worship other gods, then should it be that you people should stop sending missionaries to unreached people? It is a fact that more people reject Christ than those who receive him. I believe you will be giving more people a chance to go to your heaven by not preaching to them.
So there really is no assurance if one is saved or not. Still ONLY YOUR GOD KNOWS THOSE WHO ARE TRULY HIS. No one really has the inside info of who He is going to save or not.
As to my grandparents, are you saying that if they worshipped their gods out of innocence they will be excused? At least thats what I get from what you said.
If it is true that there is no mourning in heaven, will you just (or will your God wipe out all memories of your loved ones or friends) forget all the loved ones you have who God is torturing in His hell? For sure not all of your loved ones or friends will be in heaven with you.
I look forward to your coming here, Carrie. I might even bring you to our tribe in the boondocks or to what was left of the place.
Peace!
But still I could not possibly have a relationship with your God who may be frying and tormenting my grandparents forever and ever. I don't understand what is so sound about that, Carrie. I am so sorry.
So the good deeds of my grandparents are not "filthy rags"?
So its all about saving our own selves now without thinking of others? For as long as we are saved ourseleves "to hell with others"(if I may borrow a common American expression)? In the story of the Lazarus man, if I will end up in heaven, I will be seeing my grannies in hell suffering forever. I answered my own previous question which you did not care to answer, Carrie, about whether one remembers his or her loved ones and friends in hell.
The reason why I can not have a relationship with your God, Carrie, is because He is not reliable as you presented Him to me.
In my first few questions, you said my grandparents are in heaven because of their being good. Now you are telling me their good works are like filthy rags. So even if they did not worship other gods (innocently or not- another confusion. Is there really an innocent worship?) they would have been tormented forever by your God anyway. Which is which now, Carrie? I am confused.
Carrie, I will say this with a heavy heart- I will rather be in hell with my dear old grandparents than spend eternity with your God in heaven. From what you said I am now sure they are there because they did not know your Jesus (no other name by which men will be saved, right?).
It seems to me that your gospel brings more people to hell than to heaven. "We don't know if your grandparents are in heaven ~ but we do know that if they NEVER heard the gospel and didn't know better, the Word says they are without sin."
ITS MUCH BETTER NOT TO LET PEOPLE HEAR OF YOUR GOSPEL. More people reject than receive it.
Which brings me to this conclusion (again from your answer): If people are saved even without hearing the gospel for they did not know better as you said, then what is the purpose of Jesus dying (the gospel, right?)? I hope you see my point, Carrie. I guess your God made me inquisitive and to not accept anything without weighing things in their proper perspective.
Peace to you, Carrie.
"it is assumed that Lazarus saw the rich man in torment." exactly my point, Carrie. You also will be seeing your loved ones and friends who did not make it to heaven, Carrie, and see them being tormented by your God who is also beside you in heaven. Haven't you thought of that, too? I hope all your loved ones make it, Carrie.
My grandparents are my god? How could you say that? Its just that I love them more than the God you presented to me, Carrie, that's why I said I am willing to spend eternity with them in hell than with your God in heaven. At least I can comfort them and they me in hell. If I accept your Jesus, how could I comfort my frail lolo and lola in heaven while they suffer in your God's hell(in the presence of the Lamb-Jesus, right?)? NO, CARRIE, I JUST LOVE THEM MORE FOR THEY WERE THERE PHYSICALLY WITH ME WHEN I NEEDED THEM. In hell, where your God will torture them, it will be my turn to be a jesus to them (since your Jesus will not do anything for them there) by comforting them. In the first place, they were there by default. They were also without excuse as you said. Your merciful God did not favor them and gave them as much chance as you.
I am so sorry, Carrie. As I have told you I am so devastated right now. I came to this sight looking for comfort. Now my burden is more unbearable than before. You tried your best. Thank you. But it seems to me that this aspect of your God- that of being an eternal tormentor to both rapist, murderers, doubters and frail old people (who were good but who happens to worship what you call idols) alike, you yourself are not so sure of (or maybe not proud- as children feel of their fathers)
I asked you a simple question which pretty much will tell me your heart about your Daddy in heaven: Will He torture forever my lolo and lola, or bushmen, etc... for worshiping idols? You have to answer with so many words that I lost your heart, when a simple yes or no would have suffice. Why can't you just say "Yes".
Again, I apologized. Peace!
By the way, the thinking of others thing is not only in this world, Carrie. I was projecting to the next life which will affect the way we behave in this life and lead us to ask the right questions to whoever higher being we are serving right now.
My Understanding is L. Ray Smith has no Followers???
He has no Church and has only a website that shares is understanding of the Scriptures. I lso conclude that he uses no-other out-side source for his belief other than the scriptures alone??? Nor has this web-site of yours been able to prove other-wise. Show me one out-side source or book that shows L. Ray Smith belonging to or spouting non biblical information???
What a cruel God you have, Carrie. Makes me wonder if you are much like Him so let me ask you this question: If it all depends on you, Carrie, would you send your enemies to your Christian burning hell to be tortured for ever and ever without even the benefit of dying? Again, a simple yes or no would give me the greatest satisfaction. It would greatly help if you would try to put your finger in a burning candle and see how many seconds can you endure. Remember, this is the character of your merciful and loving God we are talkling here, Carrie.
In a nutshell, carrie this what I have learned so far: God had to kill Himself to appease Himself so that He would not have to roast us, His beloved creations, in HELL forever. He loves us more than we can ever comprehend, but if we don’t return His affections, He will make us regret it for eternity. Wow!
Is that what you call sound (fair, logically defensible, morally acceptable) doctrine, Carrie? Again, a simple yes or no would give me great satisfaction (so far you haven't given me that benefit that I always lost your heart through your wordy answers), carrie.
Remember again we are talking about the character of your god, carrie.
So you are much like your father in heaven. At least I know your heart now. I would not send a mad dog to your hell, Carrie.
I don't hate your God, Carrie. Where did you get that notion? I just can't love him by the way you represented him. If that's the truth, as you say, then so be it. I can not love him (an eternal torment god). That doesn't mean I hate him? In fact by what you are not directly stating I am learning more about Him. I am just questioning if He is really what most christians purports him to be. I think, He is more than what you think. I look up the sky and stars at night and see the beauty of these things. If your God is really the creator, then I just don't see where your eternal hell fits in. I see the creator, whoever he is, as powerfuland one with a good purpose. My grandpa taught me that. Even the bad things that happens now. Mabe my lolo discovered something about this god that we don't. We call that God, Magbabaya- or God who blesses.
Thats why I also find contradictions in what christians are saying.
Consider these: He asks you to forgive your enemies, but he won't? Or his forgiveness has time limits.
You like to say that he is merciful, but his mercy ends only after death? Will he stop being merciful after death? I can just picture your lamb (jesus) just standing there while most of His creation are tormented. So he is not the same yesterday, today and forever as you people like to say. He would not even lift a finger to comfort? I don't understand what's sound about that.
You like to sing "God is good all the time." More like "god is good only in this life"
Carrie, I ask this with a heavy heart. Is your relationship with your god borne more of coercion (the fear of hell) than out of genuine love?
So,okey, carrie, you would send your enemies that did not have the willpower as you do to your hell. How about acquaintances, friends and love ones that did not decide for your Jesus? Would you also send them, Carrie, if its all up to you?
NO, CARRIE, YOU HAVE NOT BECOME MY ENEMY.Have I? for doubting the character of your cruel god (He is who he says he is, right? So we better toe the line)? At least you were honest enough to reveal how you have become like your papa above by your truth that you told me. Some of your brothers and sisters are not that open and honest like you. You call that hypocrisy, right?
As to timpaul, yes maybe that has some reasons. Its the influence of christians on my parents. But thats another topic. Glad you discover it, though. I've been reading your bible and so far I did not read about this Paul expounding on your christian hell as much as you do. Well, I have to read some more.
Peace, Carrie. BTW, are you the actress?
So, god is good all the time to those who are only good to him also. Thats the sense I get. How about mercy, Carrie? Will it be limited to time too?
How about acquaintances, friends and love ones that did not decide for your Jesus? Would you also send them to your hell, Carrie, if its all up to you?
Again I lost your heart thru your wordy answer, carrie? I only need a yes or no.
How about acquaintances, friends and love ones that did not decide for your Jesus? Would you also send them to your hell, Carrie, if its all up to you? Just a yes or no because I want to really know how much of your father's image is in you.
Okey, let me paraphrase: How about acquaintances, friends and love ones who REJECTED your Jesus? Would you also send them to your hell, Carrie, if its all up to you?
Thanks for your "yes" altho you really could not state it with conviction. I know that it pains you. Believe me, I understand you perfectly.
Peace, Carrie.
The point of the whole mnatter is this. Would God force Himself upon someone? That is called RAPE.
Everyone has to make their own choice. God does not send anyone to hell, they choose to go on their own.
You can not separate your eternal hell from the nature and character of your father. Thats why it pains you. You said, "I don't like the subject of Hell any more than anyone else." Therefore, for eternity, Carrie, you are willing to live with this part, character and nature of your God that you don't like for as long as you don't end up in hell. That's why i ask if you are only into this because of coecion. Truth to tell, your god is no different from hitler, sadam hussein and bin ladin combined.
I think, the creator who made so wonderful a universe is more than what ou think, Carrie.
I am at Timothy now and I still could not read anything about Paul expounding so much about this eternal hell of yours. Is he really a followeer of Jesus? If hell is that horrible, shouldn't he have explained on it more than all the good things I learned about this God of his.
Hi, carrie. I am still waiting for your reply. I hope I have not become your enemy because I pointed out how cruel a god you have and how you have even become so like him. You would even send friends and love ones to your hell if its all up to you if they have rejected your Jesus. No, I dont consider you hateful. You are also what you are because you are just like your dad, so what can I do. If I am deceive by Satan for being rational, so be it(hey, I am just created being and a product of my circumstances. Somebody must have made me this way.).
At least you are so honest with me, Carrie. I just hope all christians are as honest in their convictions as you. Yes, I have christian acquiantances thats why I know a little of your doctrines.
By the way, In my readings, I still haven't read anything about hell being thoroughly expounded by Paul as much as you. Is his message different from Jesus? Or is it lacking?
timpaul But God hath chosen the foolish things of the world to confound the wise and GOD hath chosen the weak things of the world to confound the things that are mighty.
I've always thought it was even cooler than that. Not only does Satan not know everything but when he does know something God works His will anyway. I think that there are plenty of times that God actually makes Satan do things. I know that God knows what Satan will think and takes that into consideration but I think that He also controls Him so that he will say, "There will be a mark" "There will be beheadings" "There will be one currency" etc. God is amazing and OMNISAPIENT (my favorite "omni" of God.) Omnisapient is the ability to work everything to His will even though the opposite is crafted. I love you and am having "withdraws.
I will sis. I've missed you.
hey Sir Dent we got to make a choice you say ,nobody made the choice to be born,God just put us here. Hopefully one day God will reveal to you his truths. God bless
i never said i was not thankful to be born ,but givin the choice i imagine there are plenty of people in this world ,who rather not of been born.Thank God one day these people will be thankful for his gift of life.Amen
Carrie,
Sorry for taking two weeks to respond. Yes, Carrie, Satan did and does twist scripture as he did when tempting Our Lord & Savior Jesus Christ. Jesus then corrected Satan each time with the correct understanding of the scripture. Much the same way L. Ray Smith (And not just him alone) is correcting the historical twisting of scripture by the Catholic Church and the Reformed Protestant Christian Movements.
I mean are there going to be anymore Reformations??? Can you not sense one coming??? How many more times does the King James Version of the Bible need to be literally corrected??? How many revisions have already been done??? More and more Greek, Hebrew and Aramaic Christian Texts are being discovered each decade.
People will clamor for the True Text Meaning word for word. This is a tsunami that will not be stopped. Your blog really shows this when you were debating with Thad, he was sourcing scripture thru a more recent-updated version of Strong's Concordance and it seems you were quoting from or using an out-dated Strong's Concordance.
My point being is that more and more sources of earlier Christian manuscripts are clearly defining and correcting as well as making a more clear understanding of Gods word as oppose to the many manuscripts from a later period that have and were misrepresenting Gods word thru scripture adding, misinterpretation and or if not down right manipulation. Examples: such as the additions of Mark 16:9–20. The misinterpretation of Isaiah 14:12-14. The possible manipulation of verses such as Mathew 18:11 not found in any Modern Translation. These verses were added, misinterpreted or manipulated later than a majority of most historical manuscripts of an earlier period.
All of Christendom will come up against these manuscript dealings of true scriptural understanding. I for one have my own conscience and need no one to tell me what God’s word is or means (Was this not what Martin Luther’s Letter to the Catholic Church was all about?. It changed Religious Thinking on a grand world scale) Although, I am not an L. Ray Smith follower, I believe he is a harbinger of more of this to come and it is a very healthy and good thing!
By the way, my understanding is that L. Ray Smith is saved by the sacrificial blood of Jesus Christ and according to his website he has confessed his sins to the Lord and by Gods grace is saved. He also, on his website, calls for all Men to eagerly come to Christ and to be saved NOW! Not later.
With Love,
Putt B.
t raf says:
3 days ago
hey Sir Dent we got to make a choice you say ,nobody made the choice to be born,God just put us here. Hopefully one day God will reveal to you his truths. God bless
SirDent: You are right. We had no choice but to be born. After we are born and come to the knowledge of God, then we make choices. We make them every single day of our lives. God doesn't make our choices for us, nor does He force people to follow Him.
Hi carrie,
Finally, I have finished the bible. It has lots of contradictions. Paul and Jesus dont have the same spirit. Jesus sometimes contradicts himself. I like the writings of paul. You are wrong about your Jesus. He speaks of the kingdom of heaven or God more often than hell. Please count it again. If hell is that eternal and he would just stand there while the enemies of the cross are being tormented, why would he offer the living water at the end of Revelations. Either he contradicts himself or one these truths can be fitted to fit with the other. I am learning, carrie...
Saddam, hitler, hussein tortured both innocents and "those without excuse" alike which is very much like your God. These men will not take no for an answer much like the God that you represent, carrie, and will be spending eternity with.
Well, the fact that your father will torture for eternity makes him like them, don't you think? He is even worst. At least with these men, the torture will end.But your god? ughh!!! And you also, carrie, because you are even willing to send loved ones, friends and acquiantances who are without excuse to your hell. Now I wonder who is being deceived. Really...
"He spoke of hell more than heaven." This what you said, carrie.
In your effort to defend the cruelty of your god, you were careless in saying that Jesus spoke of hell more than heaven. I hope you can defend that when all of us will account for all the careless words/statements we utter. In the NIV that I am reading, in Matthew alone, Jesus spoke the word hell only seven (7) times. I gave your statement a little leeway so I counted also darkness, fire and fiery furnace and destruction. Only 16 all in all, carrie. I also counted the word heaven and only those that came out of Jesus lips and I reached 55, carrie. I did not even include kingdom, kingdom of God, or even eternal life. Need I count Mark, Luke and John, Carrie. You are wrong, carrie.
I am not hostile towards God. In fact I am beggining to like the God that Paul represents. I am also beggining to understand this Jesus, his heart, when I counted how many times he spoke heaven and hell. Maybe the living water will always be offered until everyone has his fill. The picture is even more beautiful when one realizes that who wouldn't drink water upon being exposed to the fire. Ain't that a little amusing,Carrie?
I don't think you have the spirit of the great shepherd (the living water, right?) who will not leave the 100th sheep behind.
I am hostile towards the god that you represent and preach, carrie.
Yes, I read fast.
Again, I wonder who is of Satan, carrie. If a belief system would make me send my loved ones, friends and acquiantances to endless torture by the very object of my worship because they did not believe as I did, then I don't think that is of God who created the heavens and the earth. Look at the stars at night, carrie, and ask youself: Is my god that cruel?
Peace, carrie.
What I dont like is your version of god, carrie.
Carrie,
Yes L. Ray Smith in fact, does urge everyone to come unto Jesus as their savior, but that according to scripture John 6:44 –“No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day”-KJV. He also confesses to be “Born-Again” Just check-out his e-mail section and read. Yet there are lots that I disagree with Mr. Smith on many fronts, I have learned a lot from him scripturally by going over his many e-mails. The point I was trying to make is that L. Ray Smith is not a cult; he is not the leader of a cult and is not building a church. In fact he is not attempting to mislead anyone away or to God.
He is one man with theological differences and created a website to share and express those thoughts for a lively debate on theological points of scripture. If you have created your website to challenge those view points then please share them in good faith backing your self up in scripture. Comparing scripture with scripture and by scripture show where he is wrong. I see that you too have particular points of view, but why all the evil diatribe of name calling, associating someone with the devil and calling someone a cult. Sounds to me that you lessen the theological discussion by name calling, or attempting to label someone a cult, when in fact he has no followers and is a confessed born again believer.
Have you no Christian Decency? Did God call on you to hurl insults and label someone of the devil because he has a theological difference?? I mean, on my last post I was merely making reference to historical, Christian Scholastic facts about the bible and you out and out label me as in league with cultist. What’s up with that? Who are you trying to save (When you can’t save anyone, only Jesus can John 6:44 –“No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day”-KJV.)
Carrie, once again Mark 16:9–20 is an addition of verses that appeared in later Christian manuscripts after the 4th Century and these verses appear nowhere in the earliest known manuscripts. That’s a fact! All modern translations of the Bible make notations of that to inform the reader. Only the KJV does not make mention. (Does not mean the Bible is corrupt, just means that the earliest Christian manuscripts back to the age when the Apostles were still walking this earth, these early manuscripts just did not have these later additions) This may not mean anything to you, but it does to a lot of other Christian Believers and I’m not talking about any cultist Christian Believers.
Also, the passages of Isaiah 14:12-14: “12) How art thou fallen from heaven, O Lucifer, son of the morning! How art thou cut down to the ground, which didst weaken the nations! 13) For thou hast said in thine heart, I will ascend into heaven, I will exalt my throne above the stars of God: I will sit also upon the mount of the congregation, in the sides of the north: 14) I will ascend above the heights of the clouds; I will be like the most High.”-KJV
Many a preacher had taught that this was about Satan falling from heaven; many a writer, painter and poet have expressed great works of art over this passage, when in fact it’s a mistranslation of the Hebrew word for “Howl”. From Hebrew to Latin to a Middle English Translation; we go from Howl to Lucifer and then somehow preachers or readers view this as the Devil falling from heaven??? This verse has nothing to do with Satan and all modern translated Bibles (NIV, ESV, NASB, HCSB, WYC, Amplified, New Living and The Message) point this out and have corrected the Latin translation or out and out corrected the translation to reflect the original Hebrew intent. (Does not mean the Bible is corrupt, just means that the earliest Christian manuscripts in Hebrew back to the age when the Apostles were still walking this earth, these early manuscripts identify the verses true meaning and intent) This passage is talking about the King of Babylon; not Satan. This may not mean anything to you, but it does to a lot of other Christian Believers and I’m not talking about any cultist Christian Believers.
Even Mathew 18:11 this verse omitted in almost all modern translations. Not just this verse alone, there are many more like it. Just look up omitted bible verses on a Google search and then grab any KJV Bible and any Modern Translation like the NIV and see that Mathew 18:11 and many others like it have been omitted. Why??? Because modern biblical Scholars have found and or concluded that this verse and other verses were added to the Bible after the 3rd, 4th & 5th centuries and are found nowhere in any early Christian manuscripts THIS IS A FACT! It’s not up for debate. (Does not mean the Bible is corrupt, just means that the earliest Christian manuscripts back to the age when the Apostles were still walking this earth, these early manuscripts just did not have Matthew 18:11) This may not mean anything to you, but it does to a lot of other Christian Believers and I’m not talking about any cultist Christian Believers.
But Carrie, you just shrug all this off as “I do not believe the Bible is corrupt. This is the consistent argument of all cults” Talk about hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil mentality. Then to throw the Cult Bomb Word in there, Wow! You can put your hands to your ears and scream loudly la, La, LA, LAH, LAH all you want, but the tsunami of word for word and true literal translation is coming “Eternity” will revert to “Age” or “Age-Abiding” and “Hell” (Norse Pagan Word) will revert to “Grave”, “Pit” or “Gahenna”. So instead of just digesting scriptural milk, let’s debate the scriptural solid food and leave all the Devil, Cult labeling at home.
You said, “Like any LIE, once someone decides to change the meaning of one thing, they have to then keep changing and changing and changing the meanings of many things, ending up in a perverted doctrine” L. Ray Smith would, with absolute resolve, agree with you on such a statement and he has gone to such great lengths to share and show that by comparing scripture to scripture.
Carrie, we agree that the bible is not corrupt right? The thousands and thousands of Early Christian Manuscripts attest to this. However, you must admit that the revered King James Version is not a pure 'translation' out of the original Hebrew and Greek manuscripts, but rather is a revision of other translations including the Catholic Latin Vulgate by Jerome. Did you know that the 1611 King James Bibles contained fourteen additional books that are no longer found in the modern King James Bible? Which edition was "inerrant or corrupt" the one with the fourteen additional books or the ones with-out the fourteen additional books? We are not talking about a word or two here, we are talking about whole books disappearing from the King James Version!!!
Have you seen the new King James Version? Why did they produce a new version with different words in it if the old King James Version was "inerrant or corrupt?" The KJV translates "sheol" (The Grave) into the English word "grave" 31 times and it translates the same Hebrew word "sheol" into the English word "hell" 31 times. Would you call that "inerrant or corrupt?" Which is it, the grave or hell? You seem to not understand that? How are you helping anyone if you are not prepared to know these translation errors and yet say someone else, probably someone in league with the Devil is attempting to twist the scripture? When there is clear evidence that scripture has translation issues. How many revisions of revisions do we have to endure until the true translation comes upon the scene?
Did you know that many modern language translations are dropping the translation of "hell" in the Old Testament (I’m not talking about some Christian Cult Translation). That's because they have checked and found that the KJV translations, were in absolute error on this subject. The Holy Spirit inspired the New Testament to be written in Greek. When a New Testament writer quotes from the Old Testament Hebrew, the Holy Spirit inspired them to translate the Hebrew word "sheol" (the g
Carrie -----------------------Here is the rest of my comments that were cut of when posting earlier --------- Sorry for being so long winded.
Let's pick it up here: Did you know that many modern language translations are dropping the translation of "hell" in the Old Testament (I’m not talking about some Christian Cult Translation). That's because they have checked and found that the KJV translations, were in absolute error on this subject. The Holy Spirit inspired the New Testament to be written in Greek. When a New Testament writer quotes from the Old Testament Hebrew, the Holy Spirit inspired them to translate the Hebrew word "sheol" (the grave, erroneously translated hell half of the time) into the Greek word "HADES." So the Hebrew "sheol" (grave) and the Greek "hades" are synonymous--they have the same meaning, and yet, and Yet the KJV translations translate the Greek word hades (the Unseen, the abode of the dead, the Grave) into the word "hell" 99% of the time!
Why not only 50% of the time as in the Old Testament? But now to the 1%. What about that One Percent (actually only One Time) that the KJV did Not translate the Greek word "hades" into the English word "hell." What happened there? I'll show you. I Cor. 15:55, "O death, where is thy sting? O grave [Greek 'hades' always translated 'hell' elsewhere in the New Testament], where is thy victory?"
Did you catch that, Carrie; In I Cor. 15:55 the KJV translators translated the Greek word not "hell" but "Grave." Why? Why just this Once? Why because in this verse there is "Victory" over This "Hades" over This "Grave" over This "Hell" but the deceitful translators following pagan traditions wanted to deceive the readers on this one verse. They didn't want anyone to know that there is victory over Hades which they always translate as hell in the New Testament!!!
Carrie, I think I make my point. The KJV and other Modern translations will eventually be corrected. L. Ray Smith is just one of many ringing this bell. (Does not mean the Bible is corrupt, just means that the earliest Christian manuscripts back to the age when the Apostles were still walking this earth, will be translated correctly, void of any pagan dogma) This may not mean anything to you, but it does to a lot of other Christian Believers and I’m not talking about any cultist Christian Believers.
Through Christ Our Savior, I Love You Truly,
Putt B
Your name is Carrie Bradshaw. The name of the main character of the vile series Sex & the City. Your name alone speaks volumes. I am not going to state that L. Ray is right about everything. I know that he is correct in his teaching on tithing.
I suggest she read the hub of mine about you that was removed by force.
Why does my ultimate salvation burden you? You should be glad that God isn't a rotten SOB.
Carrie,
I'll be spending the long Christmas weekend reading your HUBs "Judah's Daughter" & "Salvation: Unless God Drag Us?"
Will praise you when praise is heeded and challenge you when challenge is required. All for the greater understanding and the seeking of truth when it comes to Gods Word.
Just want to say you & L. Ray Smith do agree the same on tithing. No church body should demand tithing or require tithing of its members under our New Covenant thru Christ Jesus. True Christian believers will give regularly and at times needed to build their church and serve the Lords Missionary Ministries.
Regarding the 1 Corinthians 15:55
1 Corinthians is talking about the resurrection of the dead (Not just the resurrection of the Christian Believers).
1 Corinthians 15:55 (Young's Literal Translation)
55 where, O Death, thy sting? where, O Hades, thy victory?'
1 Corinthians 15:55 (Green’s Literal Translation)
55 “O death, where is your sting? Hades, where is your victory?”
1 Corinthians 15:55 (New King James Version) (Which is a Revision)
55 “O Death, where is your sting? O Hades, where is your victory?”
1 Corinthians 15:55 (21st Century King James Version) (Another Revision)
55"O death, where is thy sting? O Grave, where is thy victory?"
1 Corinthians 15:55 (Holy Bible in Modern English) (Ferrar Fenton Bible)
55"O death, where is thy sting? O Grave, where is thy victory?"
Even if I am willing to capitulate that Hades is not among the Greek break-down of that verse, how do these Literal Translators get it wrong as well as the KJV revisionist???
The fact is they did not. Paul in Corinthians is quoting scripture in verse 1 Corinthians 15:55 and the scripture he is quoting is Hosea 13:14, the Hebrew Manuscripts and the Greek Septuagint translates grave as (Sheol, Grave and Pit which in turn is translated in all other respects as Hades or HELL in all other areas of the New Testament.
Here are three Big Questions in regards to 1 Corinthians 15:55 & Hosea 13:14:
• What is the Hebrew understanding of Hell in relationship to “Sheol”? And how does that correlate to the Christian concept of Hell?
• When the Greek break-down of the verse 1 Corinthians 15:55 is simply Where, O death, is your victory? Where, O death, is your sting?-NIV And Paul is quoting Hosea 13:14 which is 14 "I will ransom them from the power of the grave [Sheol]; I will redeem them from death. Where, O death, are your plagues?
Where, O grave, [Should] is your destruction? "I will have no compassion.-NIV
What is the conclusion of the reader? What’s Hosea talking about? & what
then is Paul talking about, in relation to both verses’?
• When there is no clear translation to conclude the meaning of a word or verse, we are taught in Bible class (As well as Theological Seminary) to compare scripture to scripture? Is this not a clear example from Paul in comparing Scripture? He’s the one doing the quoting. I’m talking about the comparison of scripture to scripture not some later 3rd Century Christian Theory or Dogma.
This is the crux of the matter: True Biblical understanding of Gods words, the coming age of comparing the earliest known manuscripts to the later additions to 3rd, 4th, & 5th century manuscripts. You asked me a question: “So, like other L. Ray Smith brain-washed individuals, do you also believe that the Holy Spirit is not God? Just curious?
Just so you don’t run off on a bender about cults I will clarify my background
Born into a presbytery home.
Born again in the Church of Christ
Grew in Gods Spirit among the Vineyard Churches
Currently attending Fellowship Church Grapevine, TX-Pastor Ed Young.
You maybe unaware that the verse Matthew 28:19 “19Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in[a] the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” Is a 3rd Century addition to copied Christian Manuscripts. No manuscripts prior to the 3rd century have it. Instead they have "Go ye, and make disciples of all the nations IN MY NAME"
It’s something to ponder how these additions were added around the same time Christian writer Tertullian was formulating his theory and coining the term Trinity.
I’m finding my position on the trinity wavering. I’m still contemplating my position and have been praying about it a great deal.
Again I’ll be reading your HUB’s, Have a merry Christmas.
Putt B
What I find amazing about all the so called Christians of today is that none of you can agree on anything yet you profess to be one in spirit. Is this the spirit of Babel.
Why must the author edit everything? Is she afraid that the truth might set some free?
Dear Carrie,
For one so young you seem very certain that you have all the answers to questions that have baffled the rest of mankind for thousands of years.
It is not difficult to quote scriptures,however it is sometimes difficult to determine the truth using such pathetically translated and corrupted material.
The natural is the forerunner to the spiritual, and God must be served in spirit and in truth.
Are you sure that the creation in Genesis was a natural creation or was it the spiritual recreation of man?
If indeed it was natural, pray tell where did the rest of the human race come from.
If however it was spiritual, was Eve perhaps a metaphor for the soul of man? There are two Adams mentioned in scripture
Was the second Adam " The Lord out of heaven " perhaps the result of this recreation of the first Adam (the mind of man)?
Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of heaven why the concern to save the creature.
Dear Carrie,
You mentioned that this is going to be a war page, however I see it as a war against ignorance. We fight not a battle of the flesh but a battle of the spirit against the principalities and the powers in high places.The highest place on a man or woman is the mind. Rule one in the demonic battle manual is " divide and rule ".
Keep the Christians divided and the demonic battle is won.
You foolish woman taken in by and teaching the doctrine of demons and devils having your very conscience seared with a hot iron, let me ask just one thing of you.. What did the Father send his son (the word made flesh that would not fail by the Father's own solemn declaration ) into the world to do ??? Did he send him to be the savior of the world or destroyer??? Does Jesus have the power and authority to carry out the will of the Father?? will Jesus fail ?? Is salvation by the hand of God or the will of man ?? I assure you Ms. Bradshaw by the Sprit of Our Father himself, you will bow before Mr. Smith in the morning after that great day and evening.
You are the very epitimany of the anti christ, denying the very Savior who bought you..making the cross to be of none effect therefore Your condemnation is sure.. You even as the Pharisses of old shall find youself outside the gates, in the very lake of fire which you falsely claim to know something about..
Signed,
A child of the Living God, burned alive in this life, having seen the Holy One, in whom dwells no darkness at all.. Jesus is Lord and Savior of all.. He who says differently is an Anti- Christ plain and simple.. Shelah Let God be true and all men liars. :0) I thank you my Father, for you are Love.. :0)..
have yet not read that the wicked will bow before the righteous?? Have you not read what Jesus said he make those do who taught false doctrine ??? and again I ask you will Jesus fail ??? It's a simple question, one which the Father has already answered..I implore you to climb aboard, least you be left outside the gates.. :0)..
have you not read what Jesus and Paul said ?? that every man would be tested ,salted , and saved by fire even if they suffer loss they would be saved even so by fire ??? Jesus himself claimed that he would draw all men, salt all men with fire, and save all sheep.. whose side are ya on ??? The god of Molech or The God of the Lord Jesus Christ ?? Have you read but yet still deny the Lord Jesus Christ at whose name every, repeat every knee shall bow and tongue confess.. and what do the scriptures say in regard to salvation ??? Is it not written that with the tongue confession is made unto salvation ??? is it not written in the book of Daniel that there will be those who are ressurected to joy and others to shame ??? But as it is written better a live dog outside the gates than a lion dead in the ground.. Jesus, Prince of Peace , seek him Ms. Bradshaw, and perhaps he will reveal the Father to you..for you speak of things of which you do not know..you pervert the righteous judgement of a Holy God who has sent his son to save us all.. Have you not read that God has created all in sin so that he can have mercy on all ?? Why kick ye at the pricks Ms. Bradshaw.. I have prayed for you, may the Father have his way with you shortly.. In his name I have believed, the Christ, Son of God, savior of all men !!!! For salvation is not by chance, nor choice , but by the command of God himself. His name will be praised for all times to come !!! Which much love and concern from a Son of the living God.. Thank you my Father.. :0)..
Carrie,
You need to know this now. L Ray Smith is absolutely SAVED!
How dare you say otherwise? He has confessed on his website many times over Jesus is his Lord and Savior and by the Grace of God he is saved no different than thief on the Cross next to Jesus was saved!
It’s that simple of a confession, that acknowledgement alone, between the sinner and Jesus Christ.
All believers will face a final judgment at Gods Great White Throne. Any man who confesses Jesus is Lord, Lord is saved by grace and you and I cannot say other wise.
L. Ray Smith is saved! Just Like you are saved no different and in no less glory!
Now if he has a different theology from you and/or your church. That is an issue for God to judge. NOT YOU EVER! You may disagree, you may yell “demon word this or in league with the devil that”. But how dare you say that a man or woman who confesses Jesus Lord, Lord is not saved. HOW DARE YOU!
If you want to say that in your opinion he is not saved then O.K. But, praise God people will read this blog and see the absolute self-righteous attitude, much like the Pharisees back in the day. You will lose your audience with that kind of talk. Once Saved Always Saved!
In Gods Name
PB
Carrie,
The World Wide Church of God is now a member of the National Association of Evangelicals (NAE). The Church as a whole has reversed it’s self on Armstrongism and has accepted the normal understanding of the Trinity as the same as your church does.
The World Wide Church of Gods acceptance in the NAE (You might want to check, your church may also be a member of the NAE) has made right the sins of its former Cult status.
Please read about what you write about before you condemn many people as cultist. The World Wide Church of God in reality, have come over to righteous understanding and have shed their sinful ways. Where is your grace and mercy? Are you infact a representative of your church?
The World Wide Church in name, no longer exist. The name was changed on April 3, 2009 to their new official name “Grace Communion International (GCI) and have established themselves as a true church in the Christian norm.
Humble Thy Self,
PB
one must wonder why it is in the last book , last chapter, after the gwt judgement, when those found unworthy are in the lake of fire, outside the gates, why it is that bride says come,and the spirit says come, and let whoever is thirsty come and drink of the water of life freely. You know not God, nor the love of God.. You have not seen him, for if you had you would be sicken by the accusation you bring against the God of love, whom I have seen, and do declare to you is indeed the savior of all men.. with men this is impossible, but with God all things are possible. My Father is not a lair, neither is he anything but refining love, just like any decent parent would be.. Oh that you would learn the spirit of the law and not the letter, for the letter kills , but the spirit gives life.. Oh the shame to come for you !!! For my Father has declared that he will punish those who speak evil of him.. think on this my sister, and perhaps you will recieve light.. :0).. With much love to you from Pamitchrus, a son of the living God, born of water and fire, I bless your most holy name my Father !!! Send forth the son my Father, for your holy name is being profaned.. Shelah... Holy, Holy, Holy, who was and is and is to come.. Holy, holy, Holy !!! Your the best Dad , and I thank you that your words are life !!!
oh my goodness, have you not read that we all as sheep have gone astray ??? How is it you know your left from your right, up from down, but do not know the difference between love and hate ?? Have you not read that the wicked will be broken, that every man will confess to the Father that he was right, and that in him alone is truth and strength?? Know ye not that God is the same yesterday, tomorrow, and forever ?? I fear for you my little sister.. for you worship him with your lips, but your heart is far from the heart of the Father.. and again I say unto you I have seen him, and in him dwells no darkness at all.. Know ye not that God will shatter the mishappen pots and make them yet new again ?? Do you not know that God works all things according to the counsel of his will ?? and his will is that none perish ?? have ye not read that if we of all people have hope in this life only then we are the most miserable of all peoples ? Know ye not that our Father in heaven is perfect ??? Oh how I travil in birth till Christ be formed in you... answer this.. what is the will of God ?? and will he work all things according to his will ??He said that he would , is God a liar ???
Carrie,
You are bordering on a clear path of self-righteousness. The World Wide Church of God reversed it’s self on Armtrongism way back in the early 1990’s and have been a church on the righteous side of the Christian norm. Your quick desire to lash out and call this church a cult before investigating its history is down right offensive and you remind me of a modern day Spanish Inquisition.
Do not lump many in as a cult, when they have come along way to reverse themselves from that status. Condemning a whole group of people before you find out the truth, in order to help save people from the clutches of L. Ray Smith is horrendous. Your verbal slaughter all the innocent Born-Again World Wide Church of God congregation is very SELF-RIGHTEOUS Miss Bradshaw.
If you would have just stated that Mr. Smith was once a member of a church that followed the tenants of Armstrongism (This is still Questionable) then no problem. To say a name of a church congregation as being Armstrongism, when in fact they are no longer, then maybe you need to double check yourself before you do anything.
But NO, Carrie Bradshaw is wrapped in the power of the Holy Spirit and wields the mighty sword of God in the defense of saving those falling to the Grip of L. Ray Smith no matter how many people, innocent of all this hub-bub, fall in the wake.
Please FACT CHECK before you speak.
Can you not realize that you made a mistake and that you have now researched that the World Wide Church of God is a bonafide member of the Christian establishment in most of all America. Would not an apology be the decent Christian thing to do?
Also it’s kind of funny how way up at the top of your Blog you were once accusing L. Ray Smith of association with Jehovah’s Witnesses and now he is associated with Armstrongism. But it does not matter, either way he is associated with the Devil and Cults and is not saved. Even though he confessed that Jesus is Lord, Lord! You are something else Miss Bradshaw.
Regarding L. Ray Smith associated with Armstrongism:
If this were a court sitting and we the viewers of this blog were to Judge and you attempted to submit evidence that L. Ray Smith is from, was apart of, or associated with Armstrongism and you bought fourth the notes stated by Yes2Truth as your evidence, then it would be thrown out of court. You can’t submit a 3rd party saying as evidence to any court of law. You must submit a 1st person account. Go to the source Miss Bradshaw. E-mail Mr. Smith directly ask him, is he, was he, a follower of Armstrongism.
Again, I’m not a follower of L. Ray Smith and I’m certainly not a follower of Armstrongism. But there is much to learn from both when it comes to understanding the scriptures of God. I’m wise enough to discern what is insightful scripture understanding from what is of a cult. Your aiding no one with this blog, you are saving no one.
You are self righteous, condemning with out fact checking and saying L. Ray Smith is not saved, even though he confessed Lord, Lord because of your opinion of his theological difference is just down right blasphemy! Clearly you are conducting no work of God here. It would not surprise me if you again use the Name World Wide Church of God and The Term Cult in your reply to this writing. Watch everyone how she does it!
PB
Lmao.. Is God love or not ?? Simple question. and yes we are all sheep.. all souls are mine says the lord. By the way my Father is gonna whip your butt in the kingdom to come.. but a good whipping is a good thing .. :0).. when give by the God of love himself. so again one simple question.. is love love or is love hate ??? My goodness how clever you are at avoiding this simple question .. Could it be that unlike Paul you are ashamed of your gospel ?? And what you are teaching is indeed shameful and I assure you once again that My Father will shame you in the kingdom to come.. Such wicked things you say about my Father !!! All wil be ressurected in their order in the Kingdom to come.. a few will be inside the gates, the majority outside the gates where they will be untill they carry out the sentence of our righteous judge the Lord Jesus Christ himself... after which time they too will be allowed to enter the gates with untold rejoicing !!! Oh but they you knew the love of our God and heavenly Father ... One can never, ever, understand the things to come unless one understands that God is love.. :0)... and love conquers all.. :0).. Dang lady open that heart , enough of that wormwood water pouring outta your belly.. Those who believe in his name out of their belly will flow pure water of life.. Once again all will be ressurected, some to shame some to joy but all to life.. :0).. duh ...
MAT: 10:29 DUH.. God is love ... Lmao as even my Father said he will do.. :0).. You do not yet know him, I have tried to lead you to the simple truth of the gospel, but alas you are yet blinded , therefore I take my leave of you ,see you in the ressurections to come.Again much love from a child of the Living God in whom dwells no darkness at all.. Meditate on that for a while and all things will be reavealed to you.With much sorrow of heart I say goodbye. Remember, in God is no darkness all.. think on this and perhaps he might yet give you light..
Ray has not been involved with the WWCG since the early to mid 80s. In fact, he was well on his way out of the church when he was fired for beginning to teach the truths of God. He has been receiving furthur gifts of the holy spirit since. Most people who are gifted with the truths of God have their roots in one of the many cults AKA churches of this world. That's why we are commanded to come out of her.
I don't believe this yes2truth has ever left a comment on my hubs. As I recall, I couldn't gather what it was he actually believed when he posted somewhere else. I don't think we were ever of like mind. But if that's the best you can do to discredit me, then keep digging.
I'm only going to leave this one comment, and I'm gone. Yes2Truth was/is opposed to the teachings of L. Ray Smith, because he taught that a person couldn't know if they were saved until the end, and that being saved was the hardest thing in the world.
The fire is Christ.
Carrie I've read over this hub several times, and its very obvious that you avoid questions and comments, and scriptures that refute your blasphemous teachings and statements. You are a perfect example of what its like to be blinded by God.
Not trying to be rude, but that's just what I see in everything you have said in this entire hub. Sorry but you don't have a chance against the truth unless God opens your eyes.
Carrie, Isn't it curious that we both think we have been dragged to the truth? Everything is of, and from God.
12 years ago I didn't believe in God at all. He called me into a church of your beliefs. It all seemed right for almost 10 years. He did some wonderful things in my life during those years, but a compilation of things started bothering me that I just couldn't get rid of.I prayed for truth, and it was God that led me out of the church because of their false doctrine, which is basically the same as yours.I was called into, and out of it. I had to see the deception to see the truth. All of us are where we are because that's where God wants us to be for a time.Its okay that we believe differently. It is God that leads our steps. The carnal mind just doesn't want to believe this even though Scripture says so.
I don't judge you for your beliefs. Its all just part of Gods plans and intentions. Why do you judge and call those that don't believe as you to be a cult? We've all been where you are. The only way any of us could believe what you teach is that God would have to call us back to what He calls deception and lies. Its not likely that He wants us to go back to that.
Its not necessary that you pray for me, unless you want God to undo a good work that He is doing in me.He is also doing a work in you but different. All is of God.
I'm sure this isn't the first time this scripture has been quoted to you, but lets look at it again with a question.
Matt 7:22
Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord,have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in your name?
The question is who are the ones that do these things in His name? Its the pastors in the churches. No one else makes these claims. The most interesting thing about this scripture is that not one single pastor that I know of can see this to be himself. Its always someone else in their eyes because these are the eyes and ears that God has given them, but the good news is that they aren't going to burn for eternity for doing what God intends for them to do.
Everyone sees all the doe's and don't in the bible and think we can choose to do or don't on our own, but its God that makes every single little thing possible.
When I came out of your doctrines, God didn't say, darn it, I lost another one to L. Ray Smith. Only someone that doesn't know God would believe that that's the way it is.
I don't follow Ray or any man, but God does use people as His tools to accomplish His will and intentions, just as you are His tool. All of us are Gods tools, yet the carnal mind wants to think that we can do things of our own.
All I have to do is look at my life, and the way this world is to see that man can do nothing of his own. Nothing!
When Paul was on his way to Damascus to do some serious damage to Christians, he was doing it for the church. He thought he was doing Gods work of which he was, but in a different way than good, but it had a purpose because God seen that all is good. In a split second Paul was on the ground asking what he should do. Could he have went against Gods intentions by denying God? That would have had God saying, darn it I failed again, I guess I'll have to find someone else.
God makes us to be the vessel that we are, and we can do nothing about it. We can't refuse it. Paul was a vessel of dishonor, yet he thought he was a vessel of honor.In a blink of an eye God changed him.We are only what God wants us to be.
Carrie, we could toss scriptures back and forth, and what we think they are saying for a life time and accomplish nothing, but its God that does all the work in us. I've seen all the scriptures that have been provided to you by others. Its useless for me to do what they couldn't do.
I have what I call Spiritual common sense that comes from a personal relationship of having walked with God in places of the darkest and lowest places that would literally kill the average person or drive them insane. I have lived scriptures that most people know only from reading.
Gods word is Spirit, and His word is in the bible, but that's not where His Spirit lives , nor do I have to have someone quote scripture to me that most of the world can't even come close to understanding. They except it, but they don't understand. I know some very important things that you can't see, but your walk is not the same as mine.
Can't you see that people that quote scripture on and on, back and forth it goes with neither budging? Its because you are butting heads with Gods intentions. I said it earlier that God intends for you to do what you do, and vise verse. Even you trying to prove or convert us back to your way, or someone exposing you as false doctrine. I don't know what Gods reasons are for these debates but obviously its for something beyond our understanding with our weak and feeble minds and hearts.
Most people can mimic scriptures, but have they lived them, and do they have Gods word in their heart. How about you?Have you ever been dragged to the lowest and darkest place beyond your imagination and worst nightmare, shredded to pieces 24/7 in ways that one will never forget, or able to even describe, just to make you cry out to God? This is how God called me, and I'm being very honest that I put that extremely mild in the way He called me.
If you haven't lived the scriptures the way I have, then you can't prove anything to me with quoting scriptures and what you think they say.
God has revealed a lot of things to me through mans teachings, and that includes Ray Smith, but its God I count on to carry me beyond that.
All is of God. Even you, and Ray Smith.
By the way; I am not a Ray Smith follower. I studied and believe his teachings but the road to learning continues up and down the roads that God walks me through in trials and tribulations, and last but most important is that one on one relationship that comes from no man but from God Himself.
Carrie you said,"The answer is found in Eph 6:12 "For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the powers, against the world forces of this darkness, against the spiritual forces of wickedness in the heavenly places."
And I say, but its God that subjects us to these things to humble us. You know the scripture, but do you believe it?
Carrie, I've been reading this page which by the way has taken me all evening to get through and I would like to raise a few issues with you.
Be asured that Ray Smith loves Jesus and the word of God. Spend some time reading his material, He afirms these facts time and time again. You are in no place to make judgements upon his spiritual state.
You also acuse anyone who has opposing theological views to yours as being under strong delusion, or following after false doctrines of demons. This is nonsense. Just because people question the recieved wisdom of the church today, it does not necessarily mean they are deluded by Satan or unsaved. Then in your response to Roy D you quote Hebrews 6:4-6. Are you seriously suggesting that he has forfeited his salvation because he questions the church or your theology? Does questioning the doctine of eternal punishment in the LoF really equate to departing from the truth or falling away from God and repentance? Look, the Cathloic church has insisted for centuries that they and the only represent the will of God on this earth and have claimed sole ownership of the truth.
Now Jesus said that many would say Lord Lord.....did we not do this or did we not do that. He talked about many false prophets, many false teachers. Those that question eternal punishment in the LoF are not many, they are the few. If you want to see many false prophets, turn on the TV, TBN is full of money grabbing liars who persuade people with made up stories about going on day trips to heaven and hell. They claim to cast out demons. They claim God has annointed them, whilst all the time robbing the widows and orphans. You want to see people under strong delusion, look no further than the simpering audiences who laugh and clap hands at the idea of eternal torture, whilst hanging on ever word of these Word of Faith flakes.
Concerning the LoF:
Rev 21:8 But the cowardly, the unbelieving, the vile, the murderers, the sexually immoral, those who practice magic arts, the idolaters and all liars—their place will be in the fiery lake of burning sulphur. This is the second death."
Notice that this list includes the cowardly. The KJV uses the term the fearful. Who are these people? Are these people who were fearful of sharing their faith in Jesus? If so, then plenty of Christians will end up in the Lake of Fire. Some people are fearful of driving on motorways. Perhaps these people too will end up there. What about those who came to faith because those TV ministries frightened them about being sent to Hell to be tortured by Satan. Maybe Jesus doesn’t consider this to be a good enough reason to come to Him, so they end up in the Lake of Fire too.
So what happens to all these people who are cast into the Lake? They are tormented right? Not necessarily. How long are they in the Lake for? Eternity? Not necessarily. Rev 20:10 explicitly tells us about the fate of the Devil, Beast and False prophet, so we assume that anyone else cast into the Lake of Fire will also be tormented for all eternity too. But that is NOT what bible says. It says NOTHING other than they will be thrown in. To say that people will be tormented for eternity here is to make a huge assumption: it is adding these assumptions to God’s word, and thereby one runs the risk of God adding to oneself the plagues written in Revelation (Rev 22:18).
Literal Lake of Fire? Literal or symbolic of something else . Well lets look at Revelation as a whole.
Revelation 1:1 The Revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave Him to show His servants—things which must shortly take place. And He sent and signified it by His angel to His servant John NKJ
Signify • verb (signifies, signfied) 1 be an indication of. 2 be a symbol of; have as meaning. 3 indicate or declare (a feeling or intention). 4 be of importance: the locked door doesn’t necessarily signify.
Rev 1: Does Jesus literally walk around with a medieval broadsword hanging out of His mouth? No, the sword is symbolic of His word.
Rev 2: Does Jesus spend His time walking about between seven literal lampstands? No, the lampstands are symbolic of the seven churches.
Rev 3: Does Jesus hold seven literal stars in His hand? No, stars are billions of times larger than the Earth. The stars are symbolic of the angels of the seven churches.
Rev 4: Is the sea before the throne literally made of glass? No, glass at room temperature is a solid, and sea is made of water.
Rev 5: Do lambs literally have seven horns and seven eyes? No they have two of each. The seven eyes are symbolic of the seven spirits of God.
Rev 6: Are the four horsemen riding four literal horses? No, horses can only travel at 30mph so couldn’t possibly visit the whole Earth, and horses aren’t available in red.
Rev 7: Can four angels stand at four literal corners of the Earth? No, the Earth is spherical and in order to have four corners, it would have to be flat with four distinct sides.
Rev 8: Can eagles literally talk? No.
Rev 9: Is it possible that somewhere upon the Earth there is a literal bottomless pit? No, the Earth is finite in diameter, so a bottomless pit is impossible unless it constitutes a hole that passes all the way through.
Rev 10: Does thunder literally speak intelligent words? No, thunder is the sound waves generated when a high voltage electrical current turns a column of air to plasma which forces a rapid expansion of the surrounding air.
Rev 11: Do olive trees have literal mouths from which they can breathe literal fire? No.
Rev 12: Can a woman literally be clothed with the sun, stand on the literal moon, and wear twelve literal stars on her head? No, she would be incinerated.
Rev 13: Are we really going to see a literal beast with seven heads, ten horns and ten crowns walk up the local beach? No, such a thing would be no match against a helicopter gunship.
Rev 14: Is Babylon literally going to fall again? No, Babylon was completely desolate by 141BC by the time the Parthian Empire took over the region.
Rev 15: Literal sea of glass again?
Rev 16: Can a literal bowl of some reactive substance be literally poured out upon the sun? No, it would have to be a bowl of several million miles in diameter containing something extremely potent to have a significant effect upon the sun.
Rev 17: Will a literal woman who drinks literal blood ride about on the back of a literal scarlet beast? No, this chapter already gives us the interpretation of the symbology of the woman and the beast.
Rev 18: Literal Babylon falling again? No.
Rev 19 & 20: Literal lake of fire?
If we accept the opening statement of Revelation that the book is symbolic; if we accept that the first 18 chapters describe things that are symbolic; how can we then say that out of the whole book of symbolic things, the lake of fire is literal? It makes no logical sense. The Lake of fire must also be symbolic of something else.
For the Lake of Fire to be a literal lake made of literal fire, then we would have to say that real seven headed dragon type beasts will be roaming about, and people will be tormented by giant locusts having scorpions tails, human heads, lions teeth and women’s hair. If the Book of Revelation is literal, then perhaps we should take the Greek myths or Harry Potter Stories as real true life accounts as well. How many times have we seen films like the Lord of the Rings and thought, “Stuff your crappy sword Frodo, what you need is a Stealth Bomber and a laser guided fuel air bomb if you really want to take out Sauron.” In the same way, how can we believe that man will be overcome by literal mutant ninja locust-scorpion type things? Hand out the Uzi-9mms and everyone will be ok.
Hi Carrie,
I am new to Christianity although I've read alot of material on the different beliefs held by different denominations (weird that there are different beliefs stemming from one bible). I am only 14 so please be gentle!
You said this to Timpaul in one of your comments: 'We don't know if your grandparents are in heaven ~ but we do know that if they NEVER heard the gospel and didn't know better, the Word says they are without sin.'
Where in the bible was this said?
How can anyone be without sin? Romans 3:23 says 'For ALL have sinned and come short of the glory of God'
You are saying that Timpaul's grandparents are without sin just because they have not heard the gospel?
What about murderers who have not heard the gospel too?
This is confusing. As far as I know, ALL are born sinners. None is righteous, no, not one.
Also, may I know your stand on evil? Did God create evil?
Thank you!
Hi Carrie,
Thanks for your reply.
I was thinking, if people are excused because they have never heard of the gospel and God commanded His people to sow the seeds (minister and spread the gospel), isn't God indirectly sending millions to hell?
God would have to take the risk of losing more souls by spreading the word since men's free will would not confirm that they will accept the gospel. Would it not have been better for the gospel not to be spread and more saved?
I have also heard that few would be saved (broad is the way to destruction). Does that mean God has already lost (or is currently losing) the battle for souls with Satan?
Carrie, Kev provided you with more than enough to prove the L.O.F. is symbolic.
You provided these scriptures.Mt 5:22 & 5:29, 10:28, 18:9, 23:15 and 23:33; M'r 9:43, 9:45 and 9:47; Lu 12:5; Jas 3:6
Are you saying that these scriptures are literal, and Rev. scriptures are symbolic? That would be a contradiction, completely conflicting.
It seems like you didn't address the point he made with all of the bible truth. You answer his questions with questions.
Do you think I, or we don't love God because we left your kind of teachings of an evil god? We pray and seek and study Gods word. We love God and believe that He didn't create most of humanity just to burn us forever. You believe He created humanity and messed up, and is a loser of His creation to Satan, and now He has to torment all of us lost souls that He is powerless to save.
Your belief is total heresy and blasphemes.Yet this is the vessel God has made you, and you can do nothing of your own to change yourself, but God isn't going to torment you for it. He could even open your eyes just as He did us.
Yes and yes, we love God, and you call us a cult. Is everyone that doesn't agree with you a cult? What the heck is a cult anyway? Its just a stupid word that has nothing more than a stupid meaning. I have never considered anyone to be a cult. The way someone believes is not a cult. Why do you put us down for loving God. I don't put you down because you love him for what you see Him as. Just the bad things you say about Him. We don't say bad things about Him anymore and according to you we are lost and you have taken it on yourself to bring us back with your seed spreading. How many has came back to your way?
Carrie my last post was intended for The location of hell Hub.
I'm on the wrong page.
Carrie, I'm not suggesting that Ray Smith has an accurate view on everything, however he does demonstrate that a number of doctrines going about these days are unscriptural. Such as: the Christian tithe; the health and propserity Word of Faith movement ideology; the idea that man has an immortal spirit; the idea that upon death we immediately ascend either to heaven or hell; the idea that in the grave/sheol/hades there is any thought or conciousness let alone torture at the hands of the devil prior to resurection at the GWT.
It is refreshing to see though that you appear to agree that the Devil was never some perfect created angelic being that went bad. Though I have not read your hub on this, I am satisfied by Jesus' statement that the Devil was a muderer from the beginning; John's that he was a sinner from the beginning; and that Isaiah 14 was talking abou the King of Babylon and him only. This understanding of the Devil's true origin as being created bad by God in the first place makes a significant dent in the orthodox view of God's master plan from creation.
No I don't believe that Satan will be saved from the LoF. Though we may have some sympathy for the devil in this respect, Rev 20:10 is clear and unambiguous that they will be tomented day and night for ages of the ages in the Greek. However, the fate of man here is ambiguous. Rev 20:15, and Rev 21:8 both state that the unbelieving will also be thrown in, but the glaring ommision is the purpose, the torment and the duration. It is by assumption and that only that orthodoxy says their fate is exactly the same as the devil's.
Not forgetting of course that we have proven that Revelation is symbolic, the imagery is not literal. If horses do not come in red, if there will not literally be a beast with seven heads, and a womsn will not be clothed in the sun, then we must also accept that the LoF is not literal but symbolic.
When Jesus used the term Gehenna, He was of course refering to the valley of the sons of Hinnom that runs to the south west of Jerusalem and was the city dump. In Mark 9: 47-48, Jesus describes Gehenna as having worms that do not die and where the fire is not quenched. Perhaps maggot fits better than worm. Now maggots mature into flies; flies mate and lay eggs; and eggs hatch into more maggots. So worms that do not die are clearly talking about the dump being infested with maggots. Maggots are a good thing. Maggots eat up the putrid rotting filth. In medieval times they were used to clean wounds. Surgeons today use them to eat up dead flesh so that wounds can heal. So once the rubbish is eaten up, the worms die out.
Similarly, unquenchable fire does not necessarily mean eternal fire. In 2008 huge areas of Australia were subject to out of control bush fires. California seems to experience wildfires every year. These fires are unquenchable, but once the wood, the stubble, the hay, is consumed, the fire burns out. It is temporal. Gehenna was deliberately set on fire in order to prevent disease and to cleans the valley, it served a purpose.
Remember that Jesus ONLY ever spoke in parables to the crowds, Matthew 13:10, 13-14, 34-35. Therefore he was using Gehenna as a picture, in a non-literal manner. Similarly the parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus is precisely that, a parable. I have done a study of all 76 references to sheol/hades and in 75 of these there is no mention of post death torment. Only unconciousness, sleeping, and the fate shared by all good and bad, until a future resurection.
Check out the online Jewish encyclopedia definition of sheol at
http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=6
Does the single reference to conciousness and torment in this parable nullify all other 75 depictions? No that would be absurd. I had been in complete confusion over the meaning of this parable for a long time and somehow the church's interpretation just didn't fit logical analysis. Even if you never read anything by Ray Smith, I would urge you to at least read his interpretation of the Rich Man and Lazarus. It's pretty uncontroversial and to me at least was a revelation. If it was writen by someone else, you would probably happily read it, but you allow the words Ray Smith to put you off.
The main issue with Ray Smith as I see it is that he begins with the LoF refuting the orthodoxy and has then scoured the scriptures to build a case for universalism. I will agree with him that a literal LoF for eternal burning of sinners is illogical, contradicts the laws of physics and chemistry, and is contrary to the nature of God. However I see no definitve evidence for universalism, just a lot of scripture that could hint at it. You do quote some valid scripture refuting his view and after reading his entire work over the last few months, he simply does not address many of the scriptures you raise.
Nevertheless, against the orthodox view of eternal buring there are a number of issues that the church consistently fails to resolve:
After the LoF events, we have the account of the New Jerusalem. In Rev 22:15 we are told that the cowardly, unbelieving, murderers, sorcerers, etc are outside and not permitted to enter. Now what has happened here? Have these people been removed from the LoF and now are placed on the New Earth but outside the city? If this is the case, then even if the LoF is literal it would appear they are no longer being torched. If the light of God is in the city, then these people are now outside in the darkness. Literal fire is not dark, it emits an awful lot of light. Now you may say the darkness is symbolic of being outside of God's favour, etc, but then you allow yourself to pick and choose the literal and symbolic to suit your theology.
The phrase “weeping and gnashing of teeth” has six uses in Matthew. Two uses are people being cast into the firey furnace, and three uses are of being cast into the darkness. This suggests that the furnace is synonymous with the LoF and synonymous with the outer darkness outside the city. Both images LoF and darkness convey quite different fates. One of being in a firey torment, one of being wandering about in the cold in emotional torment. So which is it?
On a pure numbers game the the Devil has the victory and Jesus' mission to save mankind has failed. 1 Tim 2:3-4 states "This is good, and pleases God our Saviour, who wants all men to be saved and to come to a knowledge of the truth". It isn’t good if 95% of the population go to burn for eternity and it certainly won’t please God either. Orthodoxy is also forced to downgrade God's will in this verse to a mere wishful aspiration. How then do you reconcile this will (aspiration only) with Isaiah 46:9-11 "I am God, and there is no other; I am God, and there is none like me. I make known the end from the beginning, from ancient times, what is still to come. I say: My purpose will stand, and I will do all that I please. From the
east I summon a bird of prey; from a far-off land, a man to fulfill my purpose. What I have said, that will I bring about; what I have planned, that will I do."?
If God's will is all men be saved but this word is not accomplished, then we have a contradiction with Isaiah 55:8-11 "For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways," declares the LORD. "As the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts. As the rain and the snow come down from heaven, and do not return to it without watering the earth and making it bud and flourish, so that it yields seed for the sower and bread for the eater, so is my word that goes out from my mouth: It will not return to me empty, but will accomplish what I desire and achieve the purpose for which I sent it."
Now the fall of man did not catch God out. He is not running a disaster recovery plan. He placed the tree of the knowledge of good and evil in the garden when He simply didn’t need to. He knew that the devil who He created as a bad adversary would at some point bring about the fall. He planned Jesus as the sacrifice for sin from the foundation of the world. Everything that
Carrie,
Please Answer Kev’s Question – You seem to be skirting a crux question here?
“After the LoF events, we have the account of the New Jerusalem. In Rev 22:15 we are told that the cowardly, unbelieving, murderers, sorcerers, etc are outside and not permitted to enter. Now what has happened here? Have these people been removed from the LoF and now are placed on the New Earth but outside the city?”
Who are these People??? After the Lake of Fire events???
King James: Rev 22:14-15
14Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city.
15For without are dogs, and sorcerers, and whoremongers, and murderers, and idolaters, and whosoever loveth and maketh a lie.
New International Version: Rev 22:14-15
14"Blessed are those who wash their robes, that they may have the right to the tree of life and may go through the gates into the city.
15Outside are the dogs, those who practice magic arts, the sexually immoral, the murderers, the idolaters and everyone who loves and practices falsehood.
Amplified Bible: Rev 22:14-15
14Blessed (happy and [a]to be envied) are those who cleanse their garments, that they may have the authority and right to [approach] the tree of life and to enter through the gates into the city.
15[But] without are the dogs and those who practice sorceries (magic arts) and impurity [the lewd, adulterers] and the murderers and idolaters and everyone who loves and deals in falsehood (untruth, error, deception, cheating).
Young’s Literal Translation: Rev 22:14-15
14`Happy are those doing His commands that the authority shall be theirs unto the tree of the life, and by the gates they may enter into the city;
15and without [are] the dogs, and the sorcerers, and the whoremongers, and the murderers, and the idolaters, and every one who is loving and is doing a lie.
If the events of the Lake of Fire have already occurred and the “the dogs, and the sorcerers, and the whoremongers, and the murderers, and the idolaters, and every one who is loving and is doing a lie” has already been cast into a literal & Physical Lake of Fire then who are these people???
But, who am I to understand the Conscience and Purpose of GOD? I’m Just a sinner that seeks his Grace & Mercy.
What is your response to the question? I’m sure your readers would love to see your explanation.
Putt B
Hi Carrie,
I quote you 'Sha, keep in mind that those who love God (because they have an innate knowledge of Him) are the ones excused if they did not hear the gospel of salvation that comes by His grace and through faith in Him. Those who create their own gods and worship the creation rather than the Creator have no such grace. They are without excuse.'
Here is what I do not understand. If they have an innate knowledge of God but have not heard of the Gospel, then is it really their fault that they worship other gods (which to them, are the real deal)and not the Christian one since they've never even heard of Him?
Yet if any man suffer as a Christian, let him not be ashamed; but let him glorify God on this behalf. For the TIME IS COME that JUDGMENT MUST BEGIN AT THE HOUSE OF GOD..." (I Pet. 4:16-17).
2Th 2:3 Let not anyone deceive you by any means. For that Day shall not come unless there first comes a falling away, and the man of sin shall be revealed, the son of perdition,
Sons of perdition are the many called not the few chosen. The many called shall be disciplined, set straight through the suffering of LOSS of all their false security both physical and spiritual.
Carrie, you say I have been misled and fell away from truth.I have seen the presentations of scriptural proof that you insistently refuse to believe.You don't qualify to be calling anyone a cult. This hub supposedly inspired for us is an absolute mockery and denial of truth of which you have proved by everything that you perceive as truth. You can't see beyond your physical nose. I doubt very seriously that you have drawn any of us back to your lies.If anything you make your lies more obvious to those that come here and lead them to Bible truth, Ray Smith. Your doing a good job. Keep it up.
Carrie, never in my 56 years have I met anyone until you that absolutely knows everything, and is never wrong about anything.You sound as if you have been studying scriptures for 2000 years. Your opinion and perception goes way below me.
I guess all of my trials and tribulations, and many many testimonies of which you will never hear, and all the changing God has done in me was just my imagination that tricked me into believing was from God, but it was all from Satan instead. I guess Satan didn't want me to wrap people that had done me wrong in duct tape and break their legs. I guess Satan didn't want me selling all those drugs to the Judges, Lawyers and surgical Doctors. I gave up wheel barrels full of money for Satan. Oh and he also wants me to love and have compassion for people I use to hate.
I don't know but this Satan guy doesn't sound so bad to me considering all the good things he wants me to do and be.And the biggest thing is he wants me to pray and ask God to forgive me and continue His good work in me.He also wants me to pray for guidance and truth.
Now I'm really confused to say the least.Will you pray for me Carrie?
36 minutes late...lol. I'd saw some links on my old 'favorites' and had emailed L.Ray Smith a long time ago about some issues I had with his teachings--even gave him a very clear understanding of Easter, and how 3 nights and days in the grave worked out totally with what scripture said--his crazy response about 'a spiritual 3 days' were totally outside of what scripture plainly states.
Thanks for all your past work on this, Carrie.
Hi, carrie. Am here once again. Just want to correct you. You really said in one of your responses that Jesus spoke of hell more than heaven. Not heaven more than anyone. This is not a universalist comment. I am a restorationist.
Pray that I Cor. 14:38 not apply.
Then they said to the woman, "Now we believe, not just because of what you told us, but because we have heard him ourselves. Now we know that he is indeed the Savior of the world." John 4:42
GENESIS 2:17 God said: "But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil,thou shall not eat of it:for in the day that thou eatest of thereof thou SHALL SURELY DIE."
GENESIS 3:4-5 The serpent said: "Ye SHALL NOT SURELY DIE."
JOHN 11:26 Jesus said: "And whosoever liveth and BELIEVETH in me SHALL NEVER DIE."
Why would God want to burn people forever ? I know you say it's not God who does this but he was the one that created it, and I believe he know's everything that's going to happen. So why would go forward with a plan to have people who simply don't believe to be tortured for forever. I see nothing fair about burning anyone forever ! Even we as mere human's have a justice system that try's to give a just punishment to fit the crime. What could a person do in this speck of time we call life that could be justified for burning without end ? I love God and Im very thankful for all He has blessed me with but this subject has troubled me for years.
I was reading Psalm 103:8-9 the Lord is merciful and gracious,slow to anger, and plentious in mercy.He will not always punish,neither will He keep His anger for ever.When I read that and 1 Tim 4:10 I begin to love God even more.
It is wrong to assume that death ends all possibility of being saved for the wicked. That is unscriptural heresy. Judgment will bring about the largest salvation of humanity in the history of the world. In Isaiah 57:1 we learn that, "THE RIGHTEOUS PERISH...." So is that the final destination of "the RIGHTEOUS? I think not.
The broad way leads to DESTRUCTION. The word "destruction" is is derived from the Greek word "apollumi" which means to DESTROY, LOSE, PERISH. And Jesus plainly (I say plainly to all those who have an ear to hear) told us that His purpose in coming for His Father (I John 4:14) is stated: "For the Son of Man is come to SAVE THAT WHICH IS LOST [Gk: 'appolumi'] (Matt. 18:11). There it is. Jesus came to save all those who are 'appolumi,' which is most of humanity. Of course most Christians believe that He either LIED, or that He is INCAPABLE, or worse, DOESN'T WANT to save those who are 'appolumi'--LOST.
Ya know, we could put those two Scritures closer together and then it would make perfect sense, but OH how Christian zealots hate to put Scriptures together. They call it "taking Scripture out of CONTEXT). But as I really don't care what unscriptural Christians think, here goes:
"Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leads to DESTRUCTION [but]...the Son of Man is come TO SAVE that which is LOST [by foolishly going in at the broad gate and are now, appolumi" (Matt. 7:13 & 18:11). There are literally hundreds more Scriptures which prove this teaching of the salvation of all.
L Ray Smith
Dear Carrie
You are correct to deduce that I am not a Universalist.
Neither am I a Calvinist, nor any such title of which there are over 3 thousand in divided against itself Christendom. I do not belong to any denomination!
My house is not a house made with human hands, mortal ideas or religious set ups.
The body of Christ is NOT human-made. I am glad you’d agree.
My Avatar, Arcturus, is also as I am, and is likewise, neither a Calvinist nor any other name man gives to set up idols of the limitation!
I am a human being, housing the conception of the Spirit of Christ within, that is the Temple of the living God, who creates, you and I, all and one.
God is ONE. Behold, Oh Israel the Lord your God IS ONE.
Fondest love to you in your inspired efforts to speak, think and worship the Creator God within you.
God is love ~ I believe it, and that is Love.
Blessings
Deborah
Dear Carrie.
Deborah, quoted, L Ray Smith ~ is the Deborah that I am.
The ghost like appearing in this Thread, both as Arcturus and Deborah can be said to be as wind blowing where it wants to, not to startle, offend, provoke contend nor oppose you.
Just blowing through to Bless you.
I am thrilled that you celebrate the Glory of the Lord in whom we live and have our being.
Your Joy is contagious and a gift of His Blessing.
May the Light, that is the Christ in you, continue to increase, as His Kingdom dawns within.
Deborah aka Arcturus.
I would love to know where you got your translation of the word geenna???? Matthew 10:28 "And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather FEAR HIM which is able to DESTROY BOTH SOUL and BODY in HELL (geenna-Lake of Fire) the ancient greek dictionary DOES NOT say lake of fire or wikipedia in all reality the only thing i can find on the word points to a word [GEHINNOM] which point to a place [Valley of Hinnom]or the {Valle of the Sons of Hinnom] which is a place where they sacrificed pepole or burned there dead....untill not to long ago the word come to mean hell,lake of fire,ect.my point is plesae share where you have found you ancient translation at that was translated passede 1800 or so because to me thats about that time that word started meaning hell, fire, lakes of fire, ect.
I only have one small comment. If you are going to use Ephesians 2:8 to make a point then please use the whole verse and not half of it! Ephesians 2:8 For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God— You tried to use this verse saying it is by faith men are saved, and this is true. But! the rest of the verse says.. and this is not of yourselves. Which is "Jesus's Faith" and not yours!It is a gift from God! Lest any man should boast!
That is not ture about Universalist. I have never heard or read anything about them believing they are saved by their works. In fact, they teach it is not by mans faith or works they are saved, but only the Faith of Christ and the Grace of God that all are saved. Heb 9:27 does not say after death there is no more hope for salvation. It says it is for man to die once then be judged. Man will be judged by their works and their works will decide their just reward. 1 Corinthians 3:10-15 By the grace God has given me, I laid a foundation as an expert builder, and someone else is building on it. But each one should be careful how he builds. 11For no one can lay any foundation other than the one already laid, which is Jesus Christ. 12If any man builds on this foundation using gold, silver, costly stones, wood, hay or straw, 13his work will be shown for what it is, because the Day will bring it to light. It will be revealed with fire, and the fire will test the quality of each man’s work. 14If what he has built survives, he will receive his reward. 15If it is burned up, he will suffer loss; he himself will be saved, but only as one escaping through the flames. I don't place a title on my belief. Universalist, Traditional Christian etc. I believe in Christ. If anyone asks me what denomination I am I will say I believe in Christ. I won't put in or take out words of scripture. Do I think men need to believe and have faith in Christ! YES! Do I believe that man freewill decides if he goes to heaven or not? NO! Do I believe the fires of hell are literal? NO! Do I believe that sinners will suffer for eternity because they deserved it? Absoletly NOT!
Carrie, I appreciate your concern. As someone who onced believed as you, I would have probably done the same. However, my eyes have since been opened. Not only by L. Ray Smith, as he is not the only, but by Gerry Beauchemin, Jackson Baer, and so many others. The literature online is overwhelming. God will not torture his creation in a fictional hell forever.

















no body Level 5 Commenter 2 years ago
Dear God in heaven use this hub in Your power. Turn these people that you love to You from following one man. Use someone to reach them before it is too late even if it is not us only use someone Lord. Soften their hearts and ready their minds for you. And I pray this in the powerful name of your Son Christ Jesus. Amen